If you had to pick one fighter...

[-PBP-]

Prime Tommy Hearns, Sugar Ray Leonard and Pernell Whitaker.

Floyd is my favorite fighter at the moment but let's be real. He's never fought a skilled, slick fighter that can match his athleticism and handspeed. The closest he came to that was Zab Judah and Zab, IMO during the first 4 rounds fought Mayweather as well as anybody.

[johnm is...]

I think he gives damn near anyone absolute shit fits, but I've always thought SRL would get him.

[res]

Duran's pressure...Pernell's defense






power and reach...i think Tommy knocks him out

Yeah, as mentioned earlier Judah gave Floyd major issues for 4 rounds until Floyd figured him out. I don't think he figures Pernel out in time. It isn't as clear cut as Hearns or Robinson though.

[-jose-]

Felix Trinidad

Roberto Duran

Hector Camacho

all of these at their prime...

[boricuajr23]

I like Whitaker but would've loved to see Oscar vs Floyd in the lighterweights in their prime. I think it woulda been something great to watch.

[shade darkar]

There's really no need for a delorian. Because Martinez beats him right now at 154.

i guess martinez beats a prime mike tyson judging by the way you rate martinez!

[Weebler I]

hatton @ 140, neutral referee
pacquiao @ 147
martinez @ 154
marquez @ 135
tszyu @ 140
prime Gatti
Castillo arguably did beat him

Mayweather good at taking on fighters out of their natural weight class and in some cases past their prime

[IronDanHamza]

hatton @ 140, neutral referee
pacquiao @ 147
martinez @ 154
marquez @ 135
tszyu @ 140
prime Gatti
Castillo arguably did beat him

Mayweather good at taking on fighters out of their natural weight class and in some cases past their prime

[B Phontain]

hatton @ 140, neutral referee
pacquiao @ 147
martinez @ 154
marquez @ 135
tszyu @ 140
prime Gatti
Castillo arguably did beat him

Mayweather good at taking on fighters out of their natural weight class and in some cases past their prime

wow....just....wow

[FeFist]

hatton @ 140, neutral referee
pacquiao @ 147
martinez @ 154
marquez @ 135
tszyu @ 140
prime Gatti
Castillo arguably did beat him

Mayweather good at taking on fighters out of their natural weight class and in some cases past their prime

[IMG]http://i1147.***********.com/albums/o556/GRDW/1329179424_mj-laughing1.gif[/IMG]
________
Anyway the name I'd say with complete confidence is Hearns. Fighters like Duran, SRL, SRR, Whitaker etc. they are debatable in my mind.