Is Manny Pacquiao the most overrated fighter of the past 25 years?

[IronDanHamza]

So you can take things away from pac such as catchweights etc... (even though you know cotto weighed in the same for 2 previous WW 147 limit fights)

And then you will talk about mayweathers champion titles....where hes faught people such as Judah which was one of his bigger wins at WW...but realistically who is Judah? Hes a gatekeeper...Carlos Baldomir....

You can criticise pac...and yes some of his fans go on about him so much it begins to bring hate on the dude

But at the end of the day...Hes been the underdog for most his big fights n still wins

Barrera, Marquez, Morales.... Fighting those people alone would give someone huge credit let alone winning majority of the fights

People rip pac for the marquez fights... but how many fighters have you seen make a match even with someone who they know is completely wrong for their style..and still make a 3rd fight?

You got balls if u fight someone who is all wrong for u 3 times....

If mayweather ever had the balls pac has, he might be labelled the greatest of this era

The difference is, it took a guy named pacquiao to finally get mayweather to take some risks and fight some people we actually want to see him fight

Has he?

I have 3 by my count, and one of them wasn't a big fight.

[MindBat]

Oscar fought both guys and stated Floyd was the best.

And no, it's not because he co-promotes Floyd's fights.

[brick wall]

every fanbase overrate their favorite fighter...on the other hand his rival's fanbase will underrate him. in other words, the pac-tards and flo-mos as far as pac is concerned.

if you take those 2 out and just consider the nuetral fans, is pac overrated? i don't think so.

[Chups]

Has he?

I have 3 by my count, and one of them wasn't a big fight.

Championship/big fights where Pac is the underdog.


Sasakul
Ledwaba
Barrera
Morales II
DelaHoya


Even:

JMM I
Cotto


Overwhelming Favorite:

Clottey
Mosley
Margarito
Diaz
Barrera II

[Roman Moreno]

Championship/big fights where Pac is the underdog.


Sasakul
Ledwaba
Barrera
Morales II
DelaHoya


Even:

JMM I
Cotto


Overwhelming Favorite:

Clottey
Mosley
Margarito
Diaz
Barrera II

I doubt he was the underdog for Morales II. And, I'm pretty sure he was the favorite for Cotto as well.

[bojangles1987]

Oscar fought both guys and stated Floyd was the best.

And no, it's not because he co-promotes Floyd's fights.

No, that couldn't possibly be it.

[Pac_tard]

Manny Pacquiao, Fighter of the decade!!!!

[spyvsspy]

No floyd is. He has cherry picked his way since 140

[The Tase]

manny pacquiao is the most decorated & accomplished fighter of the last 25 years, how in the world could he be the most overrated?

Its impossible. He's rated just right.

[Mr. Philadel]

no...Manny can actually rumble...he's beaten some of boxing's biggest names under the brightest lights....Ricky Hatton on the other hand will probably dance into the HOF with no REAL justification....De La Hoya, fought them ALL...and LOST ALL the ones the really mattered....but he'll dance into the HOF with ease as well....IMO those 2 dudes are way more overrated than Manny....my 2 pennies