who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker

[MARKBNLV]

coming from you,

i take that as a compliment.

dumbass.

I crapped out better posts sloshed then you ever will.My boxing knowledge and experience you could only envy kiddo,make any subject and ill own you in your own thread.

[Future Trunks]

Hatton will most likely be inducted in the HOF.

LOL if that hapens.

[ghost deini]

whitaker all day for me and im a big fan of floyd

facts are facts though

Floyd fights guys that he knows he can beat or that are past their prime

the problem with mayweather fans/stans are that they buy into all his propaganda and don't listen to reason at all

like here's one mayweather likes to use alot

" when i fought Oscar he chose the weight, the size of gloves/ring" blah blah blah doesn't change the fact Oscar's best days where already behind him and he still only managed a spilt decision and his dad thought DLH did enough to win

his win over Marquez who is a true great looks better than it did seeing how Pac struggled with him at virtually the same weight but he still had all the advantages and came in over weight

Mosley? come on we seen what's left and there ain't much

Cotto win was good but Pac already beat him and made it look alot easier than Floyd did
Hatton was never a great fighter

Castillo and Corrales v good fighters but not great fighters in my opinion

Whitaker's resume is ridiculous he fought Floyd's uncle who we know can fight when he was only 11-0 thats crazy

and to fight DLH and Trinidad so late in his career was brave to say the least and imo he should've won the Oscar fight

and yes the Buddy McGirt win doesn't get enough credit he was a very good fighter although wasn't he suffering from some kind of shoulder surgery or problem he had

as for Chavez please Floyd wouldn't have gone near a guy like him in his prime he avoided Cotto and Margarito when they were dangerous

[Dirk Diggler UK]

None of them are close ,quit overrating old schoolers,i guess Jeff Fenech was some beast that would run boxing today huh,cause every truly great fighter on Nelsons resume beat him.

You do realise that one of the names you're defending is Zab Judah.....

[MARKBNLV]

Gomez never beat Nelson.

And, really about Jeff Fenech? Really?

Good win not taking that away,the fcks in this thread are looking for 1st ballot hofs it seems,your a good poster dude i just dont get the over hyping of past legends like todays guys would bow down,look in the last 20 years there has been a regression at higher weights but not with the little guys.compare Floyd to srl hearns hagler etc ya but to say pernell was better i dont agree,all we have is opinion they will never fight so it is what it is i guess.

[IMDAZED]

Good win not taking that away,the fcks in this thread are looking for 1st ballot hofs it seems,your a good poster dude i just dont get the over hyping of past legends like todays guys would bow down,look in the last 20 years there has been a regression at higher weights but not with the little guys.compare Floyd to srl hearns hagler etc ya but to say pernell was better i dont agree,all we have is opinion they will never fight so it is what it is i guess.

Umm...you do realize that Pernell is ranked as high as those names you mentioned?

[MARKBNLV]

You do realise that one of the names you're defending is Zab Judah.....

Former undisputed ww champion of the world,former 140 champ multiple times has beaten very good to great fighters,imo the Azumah Nelson on Mayweathers record.

[Light_Speed]

ATG > HALL OF FAMER

marquez is HOF but no ATG.


So tell me, what prime hall of famer did marquez beat?

[Tamis!]

Umm...you do realize that Pernell is ranked as high as those names you mentioned?

Here comes Azumah's biggest nuthugger.

[IMDAZED]

Here comes Azumah's biggest nuthugger.

At your service!