who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker

[The Tase]

I just told you why Whitaker's resume is better.

Whitaker beat ATG's in or close to their prime, Mayweather arguably doesn't even have a prime HOF'er on his resume. Whitaker beat Azumah Nelson and Julio Cesar Chavez with ease.

Those two wins alone are better than anything on Mayweather's resume.

Along with plenty of other good wins he has under his belt.

Joe Calzaghe was an example used to show how wrong your logic was as to why Mayweather is greater.

You're saying Mayweather had more title fights and beat more champions means he's greater than Whitaker. Why?

As does Calzaghe, as does a long list. Are they also greater?

They also have more than Ray Leonard. Are they greater than him too?

you should just stop larry.

seriously.

its getting ugly.

and dan is suppose to be on your side too lmfaaoo.

[-PBP-]

When a guy like Buddy McGirt x 2 is in your "notables" section, you know you have a great resume. He was one of the top P4P fighters in the 90s

I agree 100%. Listing those w's as just notables doesn't do McGirts career justice.

[Tamis!]

Hahaha ****in' Larry.

Sweet Pea's win over The Professor alone beats every other name on Floyd's list.

Floyd beat the more "big name" fighters, compare them with yesteryear boxers, boxers today are well known and mostly overrated coz of the internet.

[LeG00N]

your opinion is calling him an atg.someones elses opinion may say cotto,mosley,oscar,hatton are atg's what did Nelson do that was so damn great?

[The Tase]

"What makes Azumah Nelson better than Ricky Hatton?"

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

So many HALL OF FAME ATG PRIME ASININE posts in this thread.

Actually, by some of the Pernell-Chavez logic that is being used in this thread,

Floyd fought Cotto at his prime too.

cotto is not prime. YOu are not taking away the margarito, pacquiao, clottey, torres, judah wars away from cotto's body just because he fought him at 154 & 10 oz gloves.

Stop being ******.

So you went from "no prime HOFer on his resume" to "no prime fighter who deserves to be in the HOF on his resume" you're moving the goal post as you go along. Bottomline is Hatton is VERY likely to be inducted. If McCguigan got in, Hatton is getting in.

FLOYD HAS YET TO DEFEAT A LEGIT PRIME HALL OF FAME FIGHTER.

Legit Prime Hall of Famers Floyd Beat:

ODLH-past prime
MOSley-CMON SON. past prime.
JMM-past prime out of division


NON LEGIT FAKE Hall of Famers Floyd beat that might get in:

Hatton-popularity
Corrales-young death
Genaro-cancer

Fighters floyd beat that are borderline

Cotto-past prime.

Might get in might not. Still too early to tell. Cotto could fall off and lose his next 2 fights since he's talking about going up to 160.

Fighters that ARE NOT GOING TO BE IN THE HALL OF FAME for sure that floyd beat:

Castillo- i dont understand how castillo gets in other than to prop up floyd's resume.

[junior gong]

Mosleys lightweight run>>>Nelsons career.fuck outta here

You have said some dumb **** in this thread, but that is just breathtaking. Did you ever even see Azumah Nelson fight?

You say its clearly Floyd, then why didnt you just make a thread stating that you think Floyd is better than Sweet Pea? That way you would have had your own fruity little scene going on where you and a bunch of other bumsniffing floydiots could all agree with each other....

....at a toss it would have been a better idea than making one where you get made to look like a complete idiot by people that have actually watched boxing or payed attention to things other than Floyd's career and the crap that comes out of his mouth. You are a tool and a fool.

[Roman Moreno]

Most of you guys are morons,

a case can be made that Floyd is just as good if not the better boxer than Whitaker is.

So for the people that are picking Whitaker is not because of his ability being superior.

A case can not be made that Floyd has a better resume/accomplishments. Just can't.

[IMDAZED]

Mosleys lightweight run>>>Nelsons career.fuck outta here

I don't usually do this but...

Red K for posting an early candidate for Dumbest Post of the Year.

[Roman Moreno]

I don't usually do this but...

Red K for posting an early candidate for Dumbest Post of the Year.

[IMDAZED]

I mean the lengths some fanboys go smh. That was beyond disgraceful for any boxing fan.