Since we are grading fighters.. lets have some fun

[4Corners]

Mayweather, Duran, Oscar, Pryor, Arguello all had a pretty good shot at beating Pac at 140 IMO

The Mayweather that put it on Gatti in Summer 2005, has a good shot to beat anyone at 140.

[UnDeniable]

Pacquiao makes Arguello his *****, he wins that fight convincingly. Beats Pryor and makes Oscar grab his ankles

[turbotime]

Pacquiao makes Arguello his *****, he wins that fight convincingly. Beats Pryor and makes Oscar grab his ankles

Look at what 38 year old bloated Marquez did to Pacquiao. Oscar and Arguello would have beat Pacquiao up.

[turbotime]

The Mayweather that put it on Gatti in Summer 2005, has a good shot to beat anyone at 140.

Yessum he does.

[IMDAZED]

Yessum he does.

That same Mayweather struggled with Chop Chop Corley for four rounds.

[turbotime]

That same Mayweather struggled with Chop Chop Corley for four rounds.

[tredh]

I am disturbed that people are rating Margarito between a B and B+! Really WTF is up with that????

[4Corners]

That same Mayweather struggled with Chop Chop Corley for four rounds.

He won the fight by the scores of 119-107, 118-108, 119-108, and this was when Corley was actually a Top 10 Super Lightweight and was cokming off arguably beating Judah, it's when Corley could actually fight.

Ali struggled with Doug Jones at one point on his career, you can pick out any fighter who struggled with a few rounds against someone they weren't suppose to.

[Money_May]

Antonio Margarito is not a B. And kell brook is not a B (yet) either. Naz is an A-

Also prime Oscar would obliterate PAC wouldn't even be funny

[IMDAZED]

He won the fight by the scores of 119-107, 118-108, 119-108, and this was when Corley was actually a Top 10 Super Lightweight and was cokming off arguably beating Judah, it's when Corley could actually fight.

Ali struggled with Doug Jones at one point on his career, you can pick out any fighter who struggled with a few rounds against someone they weren't suppose to.

I'm aware of who Corley was. A fighter who, at his best, wasn't just a step down from an Aaron Pryor. More like a whole flight of stairs. And I'm aware of the scores. Slightly skewed because Corley did squat after the fourth. You can't complain about cherry picking certain struggles when you base assumptions on one fight (Mayweather-Gatti).