Since we are grading fighters.. lets have some fun

[RichCCFC]

Grade these guys at their peak...

-----------------
Roy Jones - A+
Bernard Hopkins - A
James Toney - A
Joe Calzaghe - A
Chad Dawson - B+
Antonio Tarver -B+
Mikkel Kessler -B
Andre Ward - A- (currently)
------------------

------------------
Oscar De La Hoya - A
Felix Trinidad - A
Shane Mosley - A
Floyd Mayweather - A+
Vernon Forrest - B+
Manny Pacquiao - A+ (140)
Miguel Cotto - B+ (or A-)
Antonio Margarito - B
Kell Brook - B
------------------

Erik Morales - A
Juan Manuel Marquez - A
Marco Antonio Barrera - A
Yuriorkis Gamboa - A
Naseem Hamed - B+

[UnDeniable]

How is Pacquiao an A+ yet Hopkins is an A

[turbotime]

Roy Jones - A+
Bernard Hopkins - A
James Toney - B+
Joe Calzaghe - A
Chad Dawson - B+
Antonio Tarver - B
Mikkel Kessler - B-
Andre Ward - A-

Oscar De La Hoya (130-140) A+
Felix Trinidad - B
Shane Mosley (135) - A+
Floyd Mayweather (130) - A+
Vernon Forrest - B
Manny Pacquiao - B+
Miguel Cotto - B (147)
Antonio Margarito - B-
Kell Brook - B-

Erik Morales - B+
Juan Manuel Marquez - A
Marco Antonio Barrera - B+
Yuriorkis Gamboa - B+

[RichCCFC]

How is Pacquiao an A+ yet Hopkins is an A

If Pacquiao stayed at 140 (no money) he would out speed guys and knock them the **** out, can't see many at all beating him at that weight in the history of boxing. 147 he's too small to **** with guys like Hearns and Leonard.

Hopkins was luck luster in so many of his fights, winning decisions and didn't care about the crowd. I have Pacquiao above both him and Toney, Toney is more skilled than the both but ill disciplined.

[UnDeniable]

If Pacquiao stayed at 140 (no money) he would out speed guys and knock them the **** out, can't see many at all beating him at that weight in the history of boxing. 147 he's too small to **** with guys like Hearns and Leonard.

Hopkins was luck luster in so many of his fights, winning decisions and didn't care about the crowd. I have Pacquiao above both him and Toney, Toney is more skilled than the both but ill disciplined.

Pacquiao and Hopkins are on the same level dude. Both have flaws, both are great at what they do and both have sick resumes

They're a notch below the gods like Jones, Sweet Pea and Leonard

[turbotime]

If Pacquiao stayed at 140 (no money) he would out speed guys and knock them the **** out, can't see many at all beating him at that weight in the history of boxing. 147 he's too small to **** with guys like Hearns and Leonard.

Hopkins was luck luster in so many of his fights, winning decisions and didn't care about the crowd. I have Pacquiao above both him and Toney, Toney is more skilled than the both but ill disciplined.

Mayweather, Duran, Oscar, Pryor, Arguello all had a pretty good shot at beating Pac at 140 IMO

[Hougigo]

Manny Pacquiao - S+

[UnDeniable]

Mayweather, Duran, Oscar, Pryor, Arguello all had a pretty good shot at beating Pac at 140 IMO

Pacquiao beats Oscar, Pryor and Arguello

[IMDAZED]

Roy Jones - A+
Bernard Hopkins - A
James Toney - A
Joe Calzaghe - B+
Chad Dawson -B
Antonio Tarver -B-
Mikkel Kessler -B
Andre Ward - B+ (currently)
------------------

------------------
Oscar De La Hoya - A
Felix Trinidad - A
Shane Mosley - A-
Floyd Mayweather - A+
Vernon Forrest - B+
Manny Pacquiao - A+
Miguel Cotto - B+
Antonio Margarito - B+

------------------

Erik Morales - A
Juan Manuel Marquez - A
Marco Antonio Barrera - A
Yuriorkis Gamboa - B
Naseem Hamed - B

[turbotime]

Pacquiao beats Oscar, Pryor and Arguello

Doubtful. Maybe Pryor.