Comments Thread For: Months Overdue: BoxingScene's Pound-for Pound Update

[Roman Moreno]

#1 mayweather

#2pacman

#3Ward

#4Vit klitschko

#5Martinez

#6Dawson

#7Wlad

#8 Donaire

#9cotto

#10bradley

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

With names still lingering like Pongsaklek Wonjongkam (previously #9) and Giovanni Segura (previously one of five “Who Could Easily Be Here”) as of yesterday, it’s pretty clear the BoxingScene Pound-for Pound list was in need of Spring-cleaning.

[Click Here To Read More]

Pacquiao #1???? After his last performance against a guy Mayweather took to school???? You guys are a joke! lol

[915angel]

whats ur top ten p4p

[Roman Moreno]

whats ur top ten p4p

No particular order

Moreno
Ward
Donaire
Martinez
Wlad
Floyd
Pac
Bradley
JMM
Hopkins.

[915angel]

No particular order

Moreno
Ward
Donaire
Martinez
Wlad
Floyd
Pac
Bradley
JMM
Hopkins.

Vit over wlad and take out hopkins and throw in chad dawson and i like ur list

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

oops, my bad

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

No particular order

Moreno
Ward
Donaire
Martinez
Wlad
Floyd
Pac
Bradley
JMM
Hopkins.

No particular order? If you are going to laugh at someone else's top ten, at least be man enough to put your self out there like he did.

[Roman Moreno]

Vit over wlad and take out hopkins and throw in chad dawson and i like ur list

Hopkins deserve to be on there more so than Dawson. And, really Vitaly should be no where close to the list. Wlad is the man at HW. He is the champ. He is the one, Vitaly is 2nd fiddle to his younger brother. Wlad has the better resume, is the first ballot HOF'er, ATG HW. Vitaly isn't.

No particular order? If you are going to laugh at someone else's top ten, at least be man enough to put your self out there like he did.

I wasn't laughing at the order of his...I was laughing at having the likes of Vitaly, Dawson, and F'ing Cotto...Cotto? Gamboa who doesn't deserve to be on a top 10 list deserves to be on it before those 3.

[-Spinal-]

Lol @ Pacquiao #1.

Since this seems like a purposely funny P4P list. I'll go along with the joke, crold, and make my very own funny Top 3 P4P list as well.

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Tavoris Cloud
3. James Kirkland

All three won their last fight without really winning it

[915angel]

.[/QUOTE]I wasn't laughing at the order of his...I was laughing at having the likes of Vitaly, Dawson, and F'ing Cotto...Cotto? Gamboa who doesn't deserve to be on a top 10 list deserves to be on it before those 3.[/QUOTE]

its jus simple fun debating,, so its ok only reason i got dawson over hopkins is you seen bernard fake that injury right??

gamboa meehhhhh still to unproven who has he beat thats elite caliber? i got rios over gambao p4p