Rate boxers statistically

[SplitSecond]

pretty sure my list is the best, if i do say so my self

[bMak]

Physical attributes is for height, reach and weight advantages? I don't know how anyone can have him above a 6 he's not a big WW and is a small JMW.

Didn't catch the weight advantage part, I don't agree with that criteria though. I'd judge that more off strength and build. A weight advantage isn't usually relevant. Floyd's been smaller than his opponent many times, but he's never been bullied or overmatched in that department.

He's average height, but has very long arms/reach for his size. He utilizes that advantage very effectively.

[LeG00N]

Manny Pacquiao

Power 8
Physical attributes 7
Hand speed 10
Footwork 6
Defense 6
Durability 8
Heart 9
Killer instinct 10
Endurance 9
Ring generalship 8

Total points:81

[SplitSecond]

Manny Pacquiao

Power 8
Physical attributes 7
Hand speed 8
Footwork 7
Defense 7
Durability 8
Heart 10
Killer instinct 10
Endurance 10
Ring generalship 7

Total points 82

physical attribute bugs me

[JAB5239]

Wladimir Klitschko


Power 10
Physical attributes 10
Hand speed 8
Footwork 9
Defense 9
Durability 7
Heart 6
Killer instinct 9
Endurance 8
Ring generalship 10

Total points 86

How in the world can you justify a 9 in the "defense category?

[bMak]

Wlads durability higher than Vitali's?

Based on Vitali's last fight? Absolutely. History of injuries, once TKO'd on an injury and stopped on a cut? No question.

*waits for the obligatory "but when he fought Lennox" post*

[JAB5239]

pretty sure my list is the best, if i do say so my self

Its an excellent list...a 10!!

[yoz]

Manny Pacquiao

Power 9
Physical attributes 7
Hand speed 8
Footwork 7
Defense 7
Durability 8
Heart 10
Killer instinct 10
Endurance 10
Ring generalship 7

Total points 83

[Jam Jars]

Power 7
Physical attributes 4
Hand speed 9
Footwork 7
Defense 6
Durability 8
Heart 10
Killer instinct 10
Endurance 10
Ring generalship 6

Total points 77

[bMak]

How in the world can you justify a 9 in the "defense category?

Easy. How often have you seen Wlad really hit hard, stunned, or hurt, over the last 5-7 years? He does an excellent, apparently underrated, job of fighting tall behind his guard.