Is it wrong to have Andre Ward P4P #3?

[-Spinal-]

He should be #4

Martinez and Donaire are the ones that are too freaking high IMO

1.Pacquiao
2.Floyd
3.JMM
4.Ward
5.Wladimir
6.Martinez
7.Froch
8.Donaire
9.Cotto
10.Bradley

Holy ****

[-Spinal-]

I think Donaire is number 3, but Andre is a much better choice for number 4 than Sergio. I don't think Sergio belongs above the Klitscko's or Bradley either.

Kessler, Froch, Bika, Abraham>Montiel, Narvaez, WV2, Sydorenko

[intoccabile]

Holy ****

Someone had him in the top 5 in this same thread. It's amazing

[Yogi007]

You can put him anywhere you want to. Pound for pound doesn't mean anything, at least not anymore. I mean how do you really compare Pac or Floyd to one of the Klitschko? Or how do you compare come like Donaire to Pac or Floyd or a Klitschko? They aren't in the same weight class and they don't have any common opponents, so the best thing anyone can do is make a guess on how they think they may stack. What it comes down to is a P4P list is nothing but a list of someone's favorite fighters.

[-Spinal-]

You can put him anywhere you want to. Pound for pound doesn't mean anything, at least not anymore. I mean how do you really compare Pac or Floyd to one of the Klitschko? Or how do you compare come like Donaire to Pac or Floyd or a Klitschko? They aren't in the same weight class and they don't have any common opponents, so the best thing anyone can do is make a guess on how they think they may stack. What it comes down to is a P4P list is nothing but a list of someone's favorite fighters.

Not really.

[S H A R K B O Y]

He dominates in a tournament, never made any excuses, is an Olympian and has never been in a close fight or lost, yet he has done nothing? Can't wait for Froch to expose Bute, then what? Rematch Froch? He whooped him. Fight Bute? He's left overs now. He's in a lose-lose situation.

I find the way most casual fans on here evaluate his style hilarious. They think he's the one that initiates the holding while fighting on the inside. These are the same fans that call Hatton one of the best 140lbs yet they both seem to fight in the same manufactured phone booth.

[gmc_rfc_06]

I have him at #3, just above Sergio.

I did have Sergio at 3, but then I thought about it; if they were to fight, at any weight from 160-168, I'd be 100% confident that Ward wins.

Donaire is the guy that I think is placed FAR too high. Ward's level of opposition is vastly superior and his manner of victory is also far superior.

[ronnie_N.]

1. manny
2. floyd
3. andre
4. jmm
5. nonito
6. wladimir
7. gamboa
8. sergio
9. bradley
10. vladimir



21. cotto

[GoogleMe]

Donaire is far from nr 3. Ward has beaten the far better opposition.

[ajohnz]

He should be #4

Martinez and Donaire are the ones that are too freaking high IMO

1.Pacquiao
2.Floyd
3.JMM
4.Ward
5.Wladimir
6.Martinez
7.Froch
8.Donaire
9.Cotto
10.Bradley

i like your list but froch at #7 is blowing my mind right now? froch ahead of donaire and cotto is an absolute travesty