Who Would Win The Rematch Now? Shane Or Margarito

[BigDog9]

lol none of them. draw.

[josenoway]

Ring doc would stop the fight again. Marg has one good eye and no head movement. He'd be eating left hands all night. That right eye would be a swollen g****fruit by the 9th.

[Bombs]

I truly believe Margarito takes it by criminal murder. In fact i think if the first fight happens again the same date without a faulty scale (which made margarito lose 2 extra pounds at weigh in) and without getting caught with plaster he would beat him. Even without the plaster..

[[ DUBBZZ ]]

Still gotta go with Shane.

Margarito's a pirate now with that one eye.

[elfag]

Mosley, for the same reason as the guy above said. Margo's face is ****ing deformed now, its not even symetrical anymore. Cotto rebroke his face and of course mosley will target that and mosley has the foot movement and speed to stay away and land on that eye.

People pick margo because he still has looked tough, he does still have a chin but he has only won 1 fight since the Mosley fight himself. His offense is ****, he is slow and his face is already broken before the first bell rings. Mosley drawing with Mora was better than Margarito's only win. Mosley also wouldnt have been stopped by cotto and wasnt even close to being stopped by Pac. He is still the better fighter today, people are misled by Margo's chin but that doesnt win fights, offense wins fights and his offense sucks today.

[talip bin osman]

shane still...

he just got to do what he did the first time around...

implement nazeem's gameplan again... those clever clinches and all...