Who Would Win The Rematch Now? Shane Or Margarito

[-MAKAVELLI-]

....at 154


they're both shot to ****


Shane is 107yrs old and Margarito has eye problems and no cement



when they fought a few years ago, people were saying that Tony was distracted and drained and that Shane might have been on something...blah blah blah


what if they had a rematch now? will the outcome be the same?

[zab191]

Margarito because of his chin and stamina. Shane I doubt has the power left to hurt him, in the first fight Shane beat Margarito by a fluke.

Margarito v El Feroz or Mayorga. Should be his next fight(s)

[Russian Crushin]

Marg

He's huge at 154 and actually comes to win

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Margarito because of his chin and stamina. Shane I doubt has the power left to hurt him, in the first fight Shane beat Margarito by a fluke.

Margarito v El Feroz or Mayorga. Should be his next fight(s)

power is last the last to go...so i dont really agree with your reasoning...not saying Shane would win but its not like he became Paulie Malinaggi overnight

[DLT]

id still go with Shane all day

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Marg

He's huge at 154 and actually comes to win

but against JMWs, he's not really as effective...when he tried to move up back then, he didn't look that great against Santos

and Shane himself, who has fought at 154, was able to neutralize Tony's size advantage

[-MAKAVELLI-]

id still go with Shane all day

why? after his last performances, you think he still has anything left?

[Russian Crushin]

but against JMWs, he's not really as effective...when he tried to move up back then, he didn't look that great against Santos

and Shane himself, who has fought at 154, was able to neutralize Tony's size advantage

Well shanes not a 154 fighter and has looked pretty bad at 154 himself.

TonyHas grown into his 154 frame, this is not the same size tony that fought santos

But overall what i look at is fighters coming to win and Shane came to win against marg last time but he wont this time. He doesnt wanna fight anymore and someone like marg would take full advantage of him at this point.

[1PnchK0]

....at 154


they're both shot to ****


Shane is 107yrs old and Margarito has eye problems and no cement



when they fought a few years ago, people were saying that Tony was distracted and drained and that Shane might have been on something...blah blah blah


what if they had a rematch now? will the outcome be the same?

really dont care who wins. mosley old and the cheater, lol

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Well shanes not a 154 fighter and has looked pretty bad at 154 himself.

TonyHas grown into his 154 frame, this is not the same size tony that fought santos

But overall what i look at is fighters coming to win and Shane came to win against marg last time but he wont this time. He doesnt wanna fight anymore and someone like marg would take full advantage of him at this point.

i hear ya...i have observed this as well...you can kinda excuse the floyd and manny fights as he was just outclassed...but he didn't look like he had that fire against Mora as well