Poll: Most Overrated Wins ever? Which one do you think

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • wladimir1988
    Banned
    Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
    • Mar 2012
    • 95
    • 19
    • 0
    • 144

    #1

    Poll: Most Overrated Wins ever? Which one do you think

    There has been some very overrated wins in boxing. I will mostly stick with the modern era because it is more fresh. Which one do you guys think was the most overrated.


    Bernard Hopkins over Trinidad.

    Hopkins was a LHW tricking people in a MW's body. Trinidad was a powerful punching Weltherweight. Despite what many boxing pundits thought there was just no way Tito could have overcome such a strength and size disadvantage. People try to justify the fact that Hopkins was a 'middleweight', but Hopkins always look way too tight stretched as a MW, he was just a natural LHW because of his cardio and living habits can marsquerde as a middleweight for such a long time.

    Pacquiao over Morales
    Pac was the new king of the jungle, Morales was clearly faded and on his way out. It don't matter how good of a performance morales put up, this was no where near a peak or prime Morales and Pac fans been making too much of a deal over those wins.


    Roy Jones Jr over Bernard Hopkins
    Overrated as hell, people always tend to add the Hopkins victory on top of Toney's saying Jones beat the 'two best of his era'. That Hopkins was green as hell and arguably 8-10 years FROM prime peak status.


    Ali over Foreman
    Got to put this old time classic in there, listening to god damn documentaries and people talk you will think thatAli just tricked big ****** george for the entire fight until 'dumb george' tired himself out and got knocked out. That wasn't how the fight went at all. George won at least half the rounds and was putting a beating on Ali, the 'rope a dope' was half trick but half ali being seriously hurt and battered. It was a great fight from both fighters.

    Foreman over Moorer.
    Similar situations, people think old Foreman just 'set a trap' he didn't set anything, moorer got too open and got knocked the **** out by old man foreman. It was just a matter of a lucky opening happening and george taking advantage of it.
    ( On a side note,, YOUNG 70'S PRIME George Foreman send Michael Moorer into a never waking coma within 2 rounds)



    Mike Tyson over every opponent he ever beat
    Explains itself I think.


    Floyd Mayweather Jr over Oscar De La Hoya
    People tend to give him way too much credit over this win, oscar wasn't quite as dead against floyd as against manny but this was maybe a 40% Oscar compare to his prime.

    Manny Pacquiao over Oscar De La Hoya
    This was literally a dead man walking


    Vitali Klithscko 'moral win the event' Tko loss to Lennox Lewis.

    Never in my entire life have I ever seen anyone get so much credit and glorification for losing at something. Up 4-2 on the scorecards and bleeding profusely from one eye with vision going blind, and a very high chance of being knocked out and with a good chance of being seriously hurt, Vitali fans still manage to spin a victory on a Tko.



    Joe Calzaghe over Bernard Hopkins

    This was actually a very very close fight rofl. That just shows how overrated mr Calzaghe is himself.
    69
    Manny over Morales
    5.80%
    4
    Hopkins over Tito
    7.25%
    5
    RJJ over Hopkins
    0.00%
    0
    Ali over Foreman
    2.90%
    2
    Old Foreman over Moorer
    1.45%
    1
    Tyson over anyone
    5.80%
    4
    Vitali's TKO loss (moral) victory over lennox
    11.59%
    8
    Mayweather over Oscar
    5.80%
    4
    Pacquiao over Oscar
    43.48%
    30
    Calzaghe over Hopkins
    15.94%
    11
    Last edited by wladimir1988; 03-11-2012, 06:37 PM.
  • ßringer
    **** Subtlety
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Jun 2006
    • 28180
    • 2,785
    • 2,762
    • 48,350

    #2
    Red K given for being so ****** as to compare Hopkins legit Middleweight win over Trinidad (a Middleweight Champion who just detonated a guy in Joppy in 6 rounds, whom Hopkins couldn't stop himself in 12) to Pacquiao's win over De La Hoya.

    Comment

    • SCtrojansbaby
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Sep 2009
      • 5960
      • 136
      • 72
      • 12,653

      #3
      lol B-Hop was 28 years old with a 22-1 record if that isn't PRIME then I don't know what the hell is.

      Anyway to put this simply every win Pacquiao's had since the 2nd Marquez fight is garbage. Except Hatton.

      Holyfield's wins over Tyson are VASTLY overrated also.

      Mosley over Margairto is also overrated Margarito was clearly not in to the fight knowing he was facing at best a suspension or at worst being banned from boxing period.

      Comment

      • 4Corners
        Nothing But Sunshine
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • Jul 2011
        • 14441
        • 485
        • 83
        • 25,167

        #4
        Ali-Foreman overrated.............Hahahahahaha.

        Foreman was killing everyone and Foreman is an ATG. Ali knocked him out. One of the biggest upsets ever, but not overrated by any means.

        Tyson over Holmes is greatly overrated, because Larry was past it. Lennox beating Holyfield was overrated. Calzaghe may not even have won that fight against Bernard. How is Mayweather over Oscar overrated??? People s**t on any fight Floyd has had, no matter what.

        Funny how you mention Tyson over anyone....you can say the EXACT SAME THING about both Klitschko's, no offense. I don't say that about either, because Tyson and the Klitschko's are ATG HW's.

        Pac over Morales was overrated in the sense that Morales had just lost to Raheem.

        I wouldn't say Foreman over Moorer was overrated. Michael Moorer was a good fighter, and George upset him.

        Ali-Foreman, the fight was close. A lot of those punches George threw weren't landing, and Ali was covering up, popping George with a couple punches and covering back up. George tired himself out and ran out of gas, Ali knocked him out. How in the world was that overrated??? That was one of the best HW wins of all-time and certainly one of the biggest upsets of all-time.

        Where's Marciano over Louis, VERY OVERRATED.

        Comment

        • J-Smooth
          Duncan is goat
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Oct 2011
          • 2551
          • 175
          • 85
          • 9,612

          #5
          nobody rates pac win over oscar

          Comment

          • Elie
            Banned
            • Jul 2008
            • 2037
            • 71
            • 13
            • 2,469

            #6
            Any of manny's recent wins

            Comment

            • wladimir1988
              Banned
              Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
              • Mar 2012
              • 95
              • 19
              • 0
              • 144

              #7
              Originally posted by The_Bringer
              Red K given for being so ****** as to compare Hopkins legit Middleweight win over Trinidad (a Middleweight Champion who just detonated a guy in Joppy in 6 rounds, whom Hopkins couldn't stop himself in 12) to Pacquiao's win over De La Hoya.

              No need to be a *******. Of course this list will offend some people. But come on man I don't even like Tito but still admit that guy was not a middleweight. And Hopkins is a massive MiddleWeight. You talking about Joppy, that was one win. Tito fought at most twice at MW his entire career going into Hopkins fight.

              I KNOW Bernard is a all time great ok. just saying beating a blown up WW he got way too much credit for that.

              Comment

              • wladimir1988
                Banned
                Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
                • Mar 2012
                • 95
                • 19
                • 0
                • 144

                #8
                Originally posted by 4CornersKid
                Ali-Foreman overrated.............Hahahahahaha.

                Foreman was killing everyone and Foreman is an ATG. Ali knocked him out. One of the biggest upsets ever, but not overrated by any means.

                Tyson over Holmes is greatly overrated, because Larry was past it. Lennox beating Holyfield was overrated. Calzaghe may not even have won that fight against Bernard. How is Mayweather over Oscar overrated??? People s**t on any fight Floyd has had, no matter what.

                Funny how you mention Tyson over anyone....you can say the EXACT SAME THING about both Klitschko's, no offense. I don't say that about either, because Tyson and the Klitschko's are ATG HW's.

                Pac over Morales was overrated in the sense that Morales had just lost to Raheem.

                I wouldn't say Foreman over Moorer was overrated. Michael Moorer was a good fighter, and George upset him.

                Ali-Foreman, the fight was close. A lot of those punches George threw weren't landing, and Ali was covering up, popping George with a couple punches and covering back up. George tired himself out and ran out of gas, Ali knocked him out. How in the world was that overrated??? That was one of the best HW wins of all-time and certainly one of the biggest upsets of all-time.

                Where's Marciano over Louis, VERY OVERRATED.

                Great points, but I think you misunderstood what i meant and what most people meant by over rated.

                Ali vs Foreman was one of the greatest HW fights of all times and it was a great upset and a incredible performance by Ali. The fact is they blew it to the point of where it make the casual fan think Ali just TRICKED george all fight and made him look like a idiot before knocking him out, When it was actually a very competitive fight.

                Idiots on ESPn (skip and his cronies) say things like 'that fight WAS NEVER CLOSE' Ali had him all along.. that was just not true

                Comment

                • 4Corners
                  Nothing But Sunshine
                  Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                  • Jul 2011
                  • 14441
                  • 485
                  • 83
                  • 25,167

                  #9
                  Marciano over Louis
                  Tyson over Holmes
                  Lewis over Holyfield
                  De La Hoya over Chavez Sr

                  Comment

                  • vironaprile8
                    Contender
                    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                    • Apr 2011
                    • 249
                    • 6
                    • 0
                    • 6,582

                    #10
                    Hopkins over Pavlik

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP