Who has the better resume Pernell Whitaker or Manny Pacquiao?

[$tate of Mind]

This thread is entertaining.

[Holywarrior]

Good breakdown,,, But the thing to consider is that pernell got a draw with chavez and not a win

[IMG]http://media1.*****.com/media/C0FcwaopmfsfC/*****.gif[/IMG]

[$tate of Mind]

[IMG]http://media1.*****.com/media/C0FcwaopmfsfC/*****.gif[/IMG]

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Manny. By far... 112-150,,, Just too much depth on manny's resume..

[yngwie]

Whitaker, Manny is great, but he never looked as good as sweat pea in his best fights.

[hhs661]

Sweet Pea.

Hurtadi, Chavez(he won), rivera x 2, Gonzalez, mcgirt, paez, pineda, haugen, Ramirez, Nelson, uncle rog, pendelton, and imo, a win over dlh.. HOW can it nut be Whitaker?

[Elroy The Great]

key opps and their age
PEA
tito (26)
dlh (24)
jcc (31)
mcgirt (29,30)
brazier (38)
nelson (32)
jlr (31,32)
rog (26)
10~ avg age; 30

PAC
dlhx (35)
timmy (29,31)
may (38)
jmm (31,35,38,39)
ssm (40)
cotto* (29)
hatton (31)
mab (30,33)
erik (29,30 2x)
15~ avg age; 35.2
*cw
x dlh moved down

had pac fought some guys when they had more in the tank.....

[fighter1234]

key opps and their age
PEA
tito (26)
dlh (24)
jcc (31)
mcgirt (29,30)
brazier (38)
nelson (32)
jlr (31,32)
rog (26)
10~ avg age; 30

PAC
dlhx (35)
timmy (29,31)
may (38)
jmm (31,35,38,39)
ssm (40)
cotto* (29)
hatton (31)
mab (30,33)
erik (29,30 2x)
15~ avg age; 35.2
*cw
x dlh moved down

had pac fought some guys when they had more in the tank.....

You're not allowed to nitpick Manny's resume. Only Floyd's resume can be scrutinized on here.

[BM dnobagaV]

key opps and their age
PEA
tito (26)
dlh (24)
jcc (31)
mcgirt (29,30)
brazier (38)
nelson (32)
jlr (31,32)
rog (26)
10~ avg age; 30

PAC
dlhx (35)
timmy (29,31)
may (38)
jmm (31,35,38,39)
ssm (40)
cotto* (29)
hatton (31)
mab (30,33)
erik (29,30 2x)
15~ avg age; 35.2
*cw
x dlh moved down

had pac fought some guys when they had more in the tank.....

I feel as if JMM 2x & Mosley are huge outliers... No Sasakul or Ledwaba.. Then again, everything can be nit picked. Also, it's 10 vs 15.
You can say Floyd fought a very young Canelo at 22 that would bring his number down, but the reality is that Canelo was super green when they fought.

[Elroy The Great]

You're not allowed to nitpick Manny's resume. Only Floyd's resume can be scrutinized on here.

im new here and missed out on the pissing contest between the clicks. im sure it was entertaining.