Who has the better resume Pernell Whitaker or Manny Pacquiao?

[SCtrojansbaby]

His win over Chavez and Nelson vastly outweigh anything Pacquaio has done in his career

lol Whitaker beat Nelson at 135 a division Nelson was clearly to small for. Whitaker had a DRAW with Chavez at 147 once again a division Chavez has no business being in

[miron_lang]

Its INCREDIBLE

Whitaker is winning? 114-100


Pacquiao's resume was already better up to 140.


I understand about who's going to win but the question is about resume.

[Mr Randy Watson]

Again, who on Ray Robinson's resume is a skilled as De La Hoya and Chavez? Does that mean Whitaker has a better resume than Robinson? Look at the WHOLE resume.



Great fighter but not as accomplished as Chavez was when Whitaker beat him.

when mentioning someone like srr, you have to take into account that it was a different time period with different caliber fighters. SRR was like a roy jones talent in his day. In roys prime he is pretty much considered an unbeatable fighter. If SRR only fought 3 times a year, there is a strong possibility that his career would have been an even greater success.

in terms of talent,You could make a case for ODLH running through SRR's resume undefeated, but its all about how you interperet it. Oscar was trained under modern methods, someone like Lamotta may not fair as well against an athlete with modern conditioning.

These arguements are always oppinion based... there is no right or wrong answer.

[techliam]

Its INCREDIBLE

Whitaker is winning? 114-100


Pacquiao's resume was already better up to 140.


I understand about who's going to win but the question is about resume.

Exactly. People are too focused on who people think would win. Can't swallow their pride to admit that Pacqiuao's resume is just better. Shame really

[Elotero]

this is true...nelson's best weight class was super featherweight imo..and chavez was the champ at jww at the time. pac beat sasakul, barrera, marquez (close/controversial win), and hatton when they were considered the BEST in their weight class at the time. 4 lineal titles in 4 different divisions is hard to deny..

Im not even going to ask how you came to the conclusion that these "wins" are better than beating Chavez. Pure Bull****. I think some of you fans are so new to the sport you have no clue how significant Chavez was during that time.

[djtmal]

what was julio cesar chavez, like, 150-0, before pernell sweetpea whitaker, pimpslapped him...lol

[mezoomozaa]

Wow

116-116 after 6 months ^^

[Prince_Pugilist]

Pacquiao. Simple. Pernell was a great fighter, tad overrated but I think H2H he'd beat Pac. Having said that, his resume isn't spectacular whereas Pac has fought and beaten almost every exceptional fighter of his generation. All that's left is Floyd.

[$tate of Mind]

WOW, Manny is leading this poll.

[CHOWWOKKA]

Marquez wouldn't have been able to knock out sweat pea...