Who fought the better oscar?

[loui_ludwig]

Julio Caesar Chavez Sr.

[915angel]

i didnt like the way he acted in the chavez fights,,, he seemed like a real ****** when he fought chavez

[hugh grant]

Tarver beat Roy Jones Jr better than Calzaghe.

With your logic, Tarver >>>>>>> Calzaghe

Tarver isnt better than JC but sure you could say Tarver beat RJJ better than JC did. Not even taking into account if the RJJ JC fought might have been in better shape.

All we are saying here is Pac beat DLH and Hatton better than Floyd did. We dont care if the DLH pac fought was or might have been better than the version FLoyd fought.

[ProTrainer]

Floyd fought Oscar at 154.
Floyd fought Hatton at 147
Floyd fought JMM at his first go @ 147.
Floyd fought Mosley out 16 months.

The last 3 had no significant wins at that weight within a year of facing him.

JMM, Mosley were in much better shape vs Pac.
Hatton was undefeated at 140 and could barely beat Collazo at 47.

Floyd stepped up 1x and lost to Castillo.
Floyd no Prime hof wins.

Pac MAB, Cotto = Amazing
Pac Odlh, Hatton beatings = Amazing

Fotd = Pac
Dotd = Floyd
Uoftd = Hopkins

[D4thincarnation]

Tito and SSM did.

But to answer your question, its an obvious fact that between Mayweather and Pac, Mayweather fought the better De La Hoya.

Even a ******* will tell you that Oscar was complete shyt and well past it. Hell Roach (former trainer) said time and time again he was done leading up to the fight.

However *******s will say Oscar cherry picked pac which some how makes the "win" legit.

And how did Roach know he was done?

He trained and seen him for the Mayweather fight.

[D4thincarnation]

Oscar took Floyd to a SD

Pacquiao shut Oscar out and made him retire in the corner.

I think it clear who did the better job?

[Slyboots]

And how did Roach know he was done?

He trained and seen him for the Mayweather fight.

He fought Steve Forbes after Mayweather and didn't look too hot. Not to mention he was well past it in the Mayweather fight.

I'd also like to say the OP is a ******, annoying ****. Please stop posting.

[RubenSonny]

Your absolutely right Quartey and Trinidad probably fought the best Oscar.

The Quartey fight was a really good fight of two young fighters in there prime at there best. I am an Oscar fan but Quartey was a beast when he got that jab going. Oscar also had an excellent jab at that point in his career and watching them go jab for jab was awesome!

Quartey showed he was declining before hand, he very bad in a draw against Lopez (even if he did deserve to win). Also he hadn't fought for a year and a half when he got into the ring with Oscar (It would've been a shorter hiatus had Oscar not purposefully faked an injury to postpone the fight).

[D4thincarnation]

He fought Steve Forbes after Mayweather and didn't look too hot. Not to mention he was well past it in the Mayweather fight.

I'd also like to say the OP is a ******, annoying ****. Please stop posting.

Hopkins probably beat the last what we can called prime Oscar, but even then he was slipping.

Almost 3 years out, doesn't do you much good, and Mayoraga, a tough fighter but a fighter where you don't need timing because he is always there to be hit, hid how far Oscar had fallen.

Roach trained Oscar for the Floyd fight and watched from the corner. Roach said it was that fight that convinced him that Pacquiao would beat him.

[Sage84]

I fought the best Oscar!

Sage KO1 Oscar de la Hoya