Mayweather and Pacquiao's Top 10 wins

[4Corners]

Not their most dominating wins or anything, but just there Top 10 most important and biggest wins of their careers.


Mayweather's notable wins
130: G. Hernandez, Manfredy, Gerena, Corrales, C. Hernandez, Chavez.
135: Castillo I, Castillo II, N'dou, Sosa.
140: Corley, Gatti.
147: Judah, Baldomir, Hatton, Marquez, Mosley, Ortiz.
154: De La Hoya

Pacquiao's notable wins
112: Sasakul.
122: Ledwaba, Lucero.
126: Barrera I.
130: Velazquez, Morales II, Larios, Morales III, Solis, Barrera II, Marquez II.
135: Diaz.
140: Hatton.
147: De La Hoya, Cotto, Clottey, Mosley, Marquez III.
154: Margarito.

Off the top of my head, here's my Top 10 for each guy if I was forced to choose right now.

Floyd's Top 10:
1. Diego Corrales
2. Ricky Hatton
3. Jose Luis Castillo II
4. Shane Mosley
5. Genaro Hernandez
6. Oscar De La Hoya
7. Juan Manuel Marquez
8. Jesus Chavez
9. Zab Judah
10. Victor Ortiz

Manny's Top 10:
1. Marco Antonio Barrera I
2. Juan Manuel Marquez II
3. Erik Morales II
4. Miguel Cotto
5. Ricky Hatton
6. Erik Morales III
7. Chatchai Sasakul
8. Jorge Solis
9. Juan Manuel Marquez III
10. Oscar Larios

What are your Top 10 wins for each guy??? State your case as well.

On a side note, they would change potentially if they win there next fights. I'd have Floyd beating Cotto at 154 as his 4th best win just behind Castillo II at 135 and just in front of Mosley at 147. And I'd have Pac beating Bradley as his 3rd best win just behind Marquez II at 130 and just in front of Morales II at 130. My point being is that plenty of people thought Morales wasn;t that great anymore after losing to Raheem, which is when Pac actually beat him. So, that's why I'd rate Bradley as a higher win right now.

[deliveryman]

Spot on.

The only adjustment I would make is moving Chavez down to No. 10, and bumping up Judah and Ortiz. I would also put Ortiz ahead of Judah.

[4Corners]

Spot on.

The only adjustment I would make is moving Chavez down to No. 10, and bumping up Judah and Ortiz. I would also put Ortiz ahead of Judah.

Yeah I had trouble with Floyd's last 3. I couldn't decide what order to put Chavez, Judah, and Ortiz. If Ortiz goes on to have a really great career, he'd probably move up considerably. But, I had a hard time putting Chavez ahead of Judah. But, I ended up putting Judah behind Chavez because the mystique of Judah sort of dropped a bit after Baldomir beat him. Had he beaten Baldomir, Judah wold have only had the loss to Tszyu and Spinks, and he avenged the Spinks loss. It would have been viewed as a much bigger win, than just another good win.

[Kagami Taiga]

my thing with the marquez wins, they dont count as good wins to me, because im a firm believer that every single fight was a draw. i dont think they are good wins, thats just my opinion.

[Emon723]

Floyd's Top 10

1.Corrales
2.Hatton
3.Marquez
4.Mosley
5.Gatti
6.Judah
7.Corley
8.Dela Hoya
9.Genaro Hernandez
10.N'dou

Pacquiao's Top 10

1.Barrera
2.Morales II
3.Morales III
4.Cotto
5.Hatton
6.David Diaz
7.Ledwaba
8.Julio
9.Lucero
10.Dela Hoya

[LeG00N]

eliminate Marquez from both and it's a good list

[ts33]

Pretty good list... Although i always thought De La Hoya was a better win that that for Floyd. Maybe 4th? And i'm not sure about Hatton being his second best win either. Definitely need to drop him down a few places i think

[Homie D Clown]

I wouldn't count The Morales fights as "good" wins. Same with Judah.
Morales came of that dominate loss of Raheem, was battling alcoholism, divorce and a huge weight cut.
The Morales Pac fought the last 2 times was a shell.

Second Barrera fight.
Barrera was coming of a close fight with Marquez but it was clear he was there for the paycheck.
he had nothing left for Pacquiao.

His first win against Barrera is definitively his best win -Homey

[The Surgeon]

[COLOR="Red"]was battling alcoholism

That true??? Hadnt heard this before...

[Homie D Clown]

That true??? Hadnt heard this before...

They said before the fight against Maidana.
That his 4 fight losing streak that made him retire was during the time he battled with alcoholism.