Donaire P4P No3?

[gmc_rfc_06]

Nonito is on the edge of the top 10, no higher.

[jrosales13]

Corboda is a 40+ veteran that is huge at the weight, a southpaw that has mixed it up with the top notch fighters. Rigondeux beat him convincingly in only his 6th or 7th pro fight ffs

Donaire has had 30 pro fights & is apparently this & that yet looking far from great vs tiny C level fighters.

Corboda> Vazquez Jr.

Cordoba was past prime man. Who best wins is probably getting robbed by Sydorenko 3-4 years prior. Besides that he didn't have a win of note in years going into the Rigo bout.

If Rigo is "this & that" he shouldn't be had the trouble with Cordoba. I wouldn't say that version of Cordoba>>>>This version of WV2.

[jrosales13]

That's your prediction, not fact. If Barry McGuigan's accomplishments were enough to make it in, I see no reason why Donaire's currently would not be.

If Eddie Booker isn't in the HOF, I don't see any reason why Donaire would be.

[FJRod]

What is P4P anyways? Really if we were to state who truly is p4p people would go crazy...Because he fights in a weak division.

[El.Naranjito707]

P4P is all opinion. Anyone can make a list and put whoever they want on it.

[-Kev-]

My Top 5 P4P
#1 Mayweather
#2 Ward
#3 Martinez

The only guys who can beat these^ guys right now is eachother. Ward can beat Martinez, Martinez-Mayweather is 50-50, I think they can both beat eachother. But within their weight classes, nobody beats them except eachother. From 140-154 no one beats Floyd, at 154-168 no one beats Martinez. I also like Dirrell over Martinez but Dirrell needs to build his name back up after that long lay off. Now if we're reaching and say a Light Heavyweight comes down to fight Martinez at a catchweight, then i'd say Hopkins and Dawson can beat Martinez, but then again that's already reaching.


#4 Marquez
#5 Wlad


#6-10, fill it up with whoever you want, don't really care.

So in conclusion, Mayweather, Ward, Martinez, Marquez and Wlad are the absolute best fighters boxing has to offer right now, IMO.

[-Kev-]

P4P is all opinion. Anyone can make a list and put whoever they want on it.

I agree with this. Too many people go by what The Ring or common acceptance is. I make my own lists depending on who I think is the best and who I think won or lost a fight. For example, I truly saw Marquez win against Pacquiao, so Marquez is my top 5 P4P while Pacquiao drops way down after also fighting Margarito and Mosley. Margarito who was not a 10 fighter, and Mosley who hadn't win a fight in 2 years and a half.

[FJRod]

To me P4P should be based on a fighter's ability to dominate current division or surrounding divisions. Just like people talk about P4P hardest hitting fighters. With that Logic Andre Ward has done more dominating in his division than Pac, May, and Marquez.

Pac Really has no Division, May has not really fought the Top 147 fighters in the last 4 ys there. Marquez been skipping divisions as well.

[-Kev-]

To me P4P should be based on a fighter's ability to dominate current division or surrounding divisions. Just like people talk about P4P hardest hitting fighters. With that Logic Andre Ward has done more dominating in his division than Pac, May, and Marquez.

Pac Really has no Division, May has not really fought the Top 147 fighters in the last 4 ys there. Marquez been skipping divisions as well.

Well in the last 4 years, Mayweather has something at WW that Pac does not have, and that's a win over the #1 WW. Pac fights guys with names, former #1 guys, former champions etc, everything former and if not then it's a catchweight.


But I agree, Andre Ward has a case of being the absolute best right now.

[straightleft]

He should have been disqualified for lack of class?? Lack of principle and discipline?? Are you insane. He is an incredible fighter, amazing athlete, ATG boxer. You don't get there without discipline and principle. I can see those are two qualities you know nothing about. And BTW why do you say Floyd is ******? What makes him ******?

Clueless? Read my sig!