Which Welter List is Better for Floyd?

[D4thincarnation]

Here are two list


The List Floyd fought: (The top 4)


Zab Judah
Ricky Hatton
Shane Mosley
Victor Ortiz

Or the list Floyd didn't fight:

Manny Pacquiao
Miguel Cotto
Antonio Margarito
Paul Williams

Which list is better?

For the first list I used my own judgment to predict the top four opponents he fought. If you disagree use your own top four and vote accordingly.

[ModernTalking]

Floyd list look like fights that would need to offer free room, free buffet, and free limo ride just to sell its ticket off.

The second list would sell out without offering free room, free buffet, and free limo ride.

[Bushbaby]

The Punisher?? Really?? I could name a handful of welterweights that didn't fight him.

[the_ilest]

the non list. obviously.

[bojangles1987]

The Punisher?? Really?? I could name a handful of welterweights that didn't fight him.

Which is very unfortunate. All the props to Margarito that he did step up to that challenge.

[ModernTalking]

The Punisher?? Really?? I could name a handful of welterweights that didn't fight him.

But these handful of welters doesn't claim to be the greatest, Floyd said he's the GOAT so he has no excuse in ducking Williams. But forget Williams, if Floyd wants to be as great as PAC is he has to knock Danny Williams or Monte Barrett out at heavyweight . Floyd: What PAC is doing is equivalent to as if I was knocking out heavyweight.

[immortal tech]

Finally D4thincarnation made a poll where Floyd losses after a few fail threads

[D4thincarnation]

Finally D4thincarnation made a poll where Floyd losses after a few fail threads

I don't know, love is blind after all.

[4Corners]

You have a hard on for Floyd.

I guess the fact that Margarito, Cotto, and Pacquiao all being Top Rank is a coincidence right???

What Welter list is better???

Floyd:
Zab Judah
Carlos Baldomir
Ricky Hatton
Shane Mosley
Victor Ortiz

Manny:
Oscar De La Hoya
Miguel Cotto
Joshua Clottey
Shane Mosley

????????????

I didn't feel the need to throw Marquez at 144 in there, because Manny and Floyd both beat him, though one did in dominant fashion, and the other arguably didn't.

[D4thincarnation]

You have a hard on for Floyd.

I guess the fact that Margarito, Cotto, and Pacquiao all being Top Rank is a coincidence right???

What Welter list is better???

Floyd:
Zab Judah
Carlos Baldomir
Ricky Hatton
Shane Mosley
Victor Ortiz

Manny:
Oscar De La Hoya
Miguel Cotto
Joshua Clottey
Shane Mosley

????????????

I didn't feel the need to throw Marquez at 144 in there, because Manny and Floyd both beat him, though one did in dominant fashion, and the other arguably didn't.

LOL, you can't help yourself.

5 vs 4 is hardly fair and why take Marquez out and not Mosley.

But I want to keep it simple and to the point, and that which of the lists are better the ones Floyd fought or the ones he didn't.

Be interested to hear from the person that voted for the list that Floyd fought.