Who has the better resume, Mayweather or Cotto???

[Mr. Fantastic]

This coming from the Mexican who hates Cotto lol. Essentially you're saying only a biased pr*ck can see it "even" or "cotto." This coming from the bias pr*ck just in the other direction. If you say its Floyd I got no problem with it, I lean that way over Cotto but the way you haters make it seem like a landslide... the Cotto anti-stans are worse than the stans themselves.

I don't hate Cotto. I hate fanatics in general and right now the most vocal idiots are the Cotto stans.

If I really hated Cotto he wouldn't even get a dime from me. He's like a skilled boxer version of Gatti. Never in a boring fight but just isn't great.

[Beater_of_ass]

Let me put it in ****** terms for the slow ones out there. When Floyd doesn't fight for 1.5-2 years, "one legged ***s" are worth more on a resume than your girlfriend because the *** was actually sanctioned. If Floyd actually FOUGHT it wouldn't even be up for debate but when you don't fight, fighting just about ANYONE hurts your legacy.

[jrosales13]

Let me put it in ****** terms for the slow ones out there. When Floyd doesn't fight for 1.5-2 years, "one legged ***s" are worth more on a resume than your girlfriend because the *** was actually sanctioned. If Floyd actually FOUGHT it wouldn't even be up for debate but when you don't fight, fighting just about ANYONE hurts your legacy.

Well there you have it folks Cotto has a better legacy than Tito Trinidad because Cotto fought Foreman and Tito has been retired.

[Beater_of_ass]

I don't hate Cotto. I hate fanatics in general and right now the most vocal idiots are the Cotto stans.

If I really hated Cotto he wouldn't even get a dime from me. He's like a skilled boxer version of Gatti. Never in a boring fight but just isn't great.

What are we vocal about? We would rather see Cotto/Floyd than the Manny fight? Its not like we're telling them to make Pac II. But if the rumors are there we are going to speculate, there must be a reason behind Manny not wanting Cotto any higher than 147. Please, don't tell me because he'd fight at 150 he would just magically not duck Sergio for some other reason. I'm not saying there aren't some lunatics out there, but don't lump me in with them. I use logic and facts to base my opinions not bull**** like Cotto was drained at 145. For some reason saying he would be better at 150+ than 145 makes you guys say "oh you said he was drained making excuses."

[Beater_of_ass]

Well there you have it folks Cotto has a better legacy than Tito Trinidad because Cotto fought Foreman and Tito has been retired.

It's sad how you come to these conclusions, ******ity never ceases to amaze.

[Mr. Fantastic]

What are we vocal about? We would rather see Cotto/Floyd than the Manny fight? Its not like we're telling them to make Pac II. But if the rumors are there we are going to speculate, there must be a reason behind Manny not wanting Cotto any higher than 147. Please, don't tell me because he'd fight at 150 he would just magically not duck Sergio for some other reason. I'm not saying there aren't some lunatics out there, but don't lump me in with them. I use logic and facts to base my opinions not bull**** like Cotto was drained at 145. For some reason saying he would be better at 150+ than 145 makes you guys say "oh you said he was drained making excuses."

I won't be saying he ducked Sergio. Martinez is a Middleweight Champion. Unless he goes back to 154, then I don't see a duck anywhere.

You guys *****ed with Margarito. Now that he won the rematch you guys act like it was the mother of all revenge fights. It was just a band aid for that broken heart and ego you guys had.

You guys think that Diaz is going to make a difference with Pac. Pac is a GREAT fighter and Cotto isn't. Top it off the difference between Pac and Margarito is just way too much. Cotto isn't good enough to beat Pac. Never will.

Logic and facts like what? Oh Margarito cheated in the first fight logic fact?

Anyways. You belong in the group of stans.

[Beater_of_ass]

I won't be saying he ducked Sergio. Martinez is a Middleweight Champion. Unless he goes back to 154, then I don't see a duck anywhere.

You guys *****ed with Margarito. Now that he won the rematch you guys act like it was the mother of all revenge fights. It was just a band aid for that broken heart and ego you guys had.

You guys think that Diaz is going to make a difference with Pac. Pac is a GREAT fighter and Cotto isn't. Top it off the difference between Pac and Margarito is just way too much. Cotto isn't good enough to beat Pac. Never will.

Logic and facts like what? Oh Margarito cheated in the first fight logic fact?

Anyways. You belong in the group of stans.

And again you guys are so ANTI Cotto he can't possibly do any better no matter what. You said the same thing against Margarito II, I remember you saying the only thing Cotto did that worried you would be pumping out the jab. Other than that he was ****, Cotto is just a vulnerable fighter and you guys just HATE being wrong. If you say Cotto sucks every fight, you'll be right one of these times even a broken clock is right twice a day.

[-Deal With It-]

Let me put it in ****** terms for the slow ones out there. When Floyd doesn't fight for 1.5-2 years, "one legged ***s" are worth more on a resume than your girlfriend because the *** was actually sanctioned. If Floyd actually FOUGHT it wouldn't even be up for debate but when you don't fight, fighting just about ANYONE hurts your legacy.

I would prefer Floyd not to fight at all than to partake in a circus fight with some clown sporting forrest gump knees and a heavily padded record.

But that's just me...

Also, Floyd's work @ 130 > Cotto's entire career

BTW, in that one year that Floyd took off, he had the exact same number of meaningful wins as Cotto.

[Mr. Fantastic]

And again you guys are so ANTI Cotto he can't possibly do any better no matter what. You said the same thing against Margarito II, I remember you saying the only thing Cotto did that worried you would be pumping out the jab. Other than that he was ****, Cotto is just a vulnerable fighter and you guys just HATE being wrong. If you say Cotto sucks every fight, you'll be right one of these times even a broken clock is right twice a day.

He can...just not against Pac. He beat Margarito I give him that but it's you fanatics that think he can do that to Pac. Do you see me making excuses for the Margarito loss? Nope. Margarito and Cotto are not in the same league as that guy. You have to remember Cotto isn't in his prime like you nuthuggers like to think. I may be more understandable if he was.

I don't hate being wrong. I'm human and I make mistakes. It happens!! You guys are the ones that think the world revolves around Cotto. Like the third best draw in boxing, if he beats Pac(lol) his resume better than Mayweather which makes Cotto an ATG, etc. If it doesn't go your way or your fellow stans, we are haters.

[_original_]

I'm sorry, I just don't like evaluating boxing resumes and including the people they lost too and giving them credit for it (unless talking about people like Marquez and Sweet Pea who were robbed of very meaningful fights). Just think about your own resume, do you include jobs you've been fired from along with jobs you had great success at? Like Oscar, he fought damn near everybody, one of the best lists of who's who in the history of boxing, but I don't think he ranks anywhere near the top 50. I just look at resume threads different than who have they fought threads. So of course I'm gonna go with Floyd on this one, not saying Cotto has a bad one, he has a pretty good one too but it doesn't compare to Floyd's. And too boot Cotto has some pretty bad losses, and really tough outings (Mosley, Clottey) that make two of his best wins look fragile as it is.