Better Resume? Miguel Cotto vs Jose Luis Castillo

[baya]

this one's close ... i'll say this much, i'll never, i THINK, have a reaction to a fight like i did in the corrales / castillo fight.

so a lean towards jlc and yes, on that night, jlc beat mayweather.

[Unknown Champ]

and this rite here is why i cant take many cotto fans seriously. in order to make cotto look good, they have to berate other fighters or over hype cotto's wins.

Shut your wack asss Dallas MAverick asss up.

It is joke, relax.

I'm a fan of Cotto and boxing, I aint no rookie blabbing nonsense with no validity to what I say when i comes to making a point.

I didnt hype anyone up that Cotto fought. Mosley alone is greater then anything on JLC resume. He fought a competitive and live Mosley to be exact.

I think Cotto fought the better opposition, its JLC supporters saying Corrales wasnt shot after his first war with JLC when he fought Joel which is not true. Casamayor is a B fighter not a top notch one like say a Mosley even at that time he fought Miguel.

Relax though I am not an E-warrior, it's just I saw all those fights along with all the pressers and fun that come along with hyping the fights. So I watched these fights live and know who these fighters are pretty well.

Lets be friends but I disagree with your comical opinion.

( I sound like a prick in the last line haha)

[Unknown Champ]

As much as I believed MArquez won the last pacman fight, he still lost and it is in the books as Manny winning, so when comparing resumes you go with facts not subjective feelings. Can we all agree on that?

[ThePrince]

If Castillo had that W against Floyd that he deserves, then it'd be an interesting debate since it would be the biggest win on either guy's record by a good margin. But it wasn't in the cards for him and IMO Cotto is more HOF worthy and his career isn't over. It's possible he might be the first Puerto Rican fighter to win belts in 4 divisions.

[Kagami Taiga]

If Castillo had that W against Floyd that he deserves, then it'd be an interesting debate since it would be the biggest win on either guy's record by a good margin. But it wasn't in the cards for him and IMO Cotto is more HOF worthy and his career isn't over. It's possible he might be the first Puerto Rican fighter to win belts in 4 divisions.

yea, against jcc jr. lol...

[ThePrince]

yea, against jcc jr. lol...

43 have tried, 43 have failed

[Ringlife]

Cotto fought the better fighters.

[SCtrojansbaby]

If Castillo had that W against Floyd that he deserves, then it'd be an interesting debate since it would be the biggest win on either guy's record by a good margin. But it wasn't in the cards for him and IMO Cotto is more HOF worthy and his career isn't over. It's possible he might be the first Puerto Rican fighter to win belts in 4 divisions.

lol Johnston and Casamayor are still the 2 biggest wins on either guys resume

[Kagami Taiga]

lol Johnston and Casamayor are still the 2 biggest wins on either guys resume

besides mosely, this is true.

[turbotime]

You're saying Casamayor isn't? He was the top lightweight when Castillo beat him. Cotto never beat anyone when they were at the top of anything.

Funny how this went untouched.