Better Resume? Miguel Cotto vs Jose Luis Castillo

[turbotime]

So you are saying Casamayor was top notch?

Dude is a FNF fighter haha

You're saying Casamayor isn't? He was the top lightweight when Castillo beat him. Cotto never beat anyone when they were at the top of anything.

[Unknown Champ]

Funny you say that, besides the Mosley win, that win alone is greater than any other win on Cotto's resume. That's not even a knock on Cotto, that's actually a testament to how good Casamayor was. So yes, Casamayor was top notch.

Who has Casamayor beat to make him top notch besides corrales (who won the rematch)?

Who???

[Unknown Champ]

The galaxy warrior?? lol

[Unknown Champ]

I'll wait.........

[Unknown Champ]

fucckin douche bag haha jk ahhh life is odd at times

[Doctor_Tenma]

That's the thing, Joel has consistently fought top notch opposition, I'm gonna respect the judges on this one because those were close fights, but I felt he beat Freitas, he beat Corrales in the rematch, I thought Castillo-Casamayor should have been a draw, he also stopped an undefeated Katsidis and fought competitively with Marquez while being well past his prime. Again, besides the Mosley win, that win alone is better than any other win on Cotto's resume.

[Doctor_Tenma]

The galaxy warrior?? lol

Nope, last time I watched that I had Campbell edging it, that was years ago so I'll refrain from giving Joel that win, I'll have to re-watch it.

[Kagami Taiga]

Who has Casamayor beat to make him top notch besides corrales (who won the rematch)?

Who???

The galaxy warrior?? lol

I'll wait.........

fucckin douche bag haha jk ahhh life is odd at times

and this rite here is why i cant take many cotto fans seriously. in order to make cotto look good, they have to berate other fighters or over hype cotto's wins.

[J-Smooth]

for the record shane and clottey beat cotto...

[-MAKAVELLI-]

leaning towards JLC