Scoring of MAYWEATHER fights by bogotazo

[Doctor_Tenma]

I gave Zab Judah 2 of the first 4 rounds, you can give him 3, round 4 was extremely close. So at most, say you gave him 3 of the first 4 rounds and the 12th round, the most you can give Judah was 4 rounds in the fight.

[GrandpaBernard]

[IMDAZED]

It's not a good poll question if you put straight up 5. I said that personally I gave Judah 4 of the first 6, and I believe I gave Oscar 4 or 5 in the whole fight. I have Mayweather winning both clearly, and I never said that Judah and Oscar each won 5 definitely, so revise your poll.

What rounds did you give Zab?

[tredh]

I saw a different fight than you did i guess. Floyd was the more acurate puncher in my eyes, but not in the sense that it was consistent. The middle rounds is when Floyd wasnt nearly as active, and Oscar wasn't pushing the issue. Even if Oscar was landing flush shots, he was still scoring. I respect your opinion, and we are all entitled to them. Just like most thought Khan lost to Peterson....I thought he won (though by skin of his teeth), and im not putting compubox into play. Thats just how i saw it. Some people score aggression, some score on %, some on effectiveness. I try to use all 3. I may not always be right, but i dont BS what i saw.

THe bold is where you and others go wrong scoring fights! Boxing has its own scoring criteria. People make up they own scoring criteria and then try to justify the scores of fights when that **** is all wrong because they made up they own rules.
Boxing is scored on 1. Clean effective punching 2. Defense 3. Ring Generalship 4. EFFECTVIE AGGRESSION. Any other form of scoring is complete BULL****!!

[IMDAZED]

THe bold is where you and others go wrong scoring fights! Boxing has its own scoring criteria. People make up they own scoring criteria and then try to justify the scores of fights when that **** is all wrong because they made up they own rules.
Boxing is scored on 1. Clean effective punching 2. Defense 3. Ring Generalship 4. EFFECTVIE AGGRESSION. Any other form of scoring is complete BULL****!!

Quoted For Truth. He's just biased and won't bring himself to admit it, that's all.

[jtiger777]

Oscar won 3 (total).
Zab won probably 2 of the first four rounds.

this!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Bogotazo]

What rounds did you give Zab?

Don't have my scorecard on me. Maybe I'll re-score the first half of each later on to refresh and let you guys know. I don't think at all that 4 rounds in either fight for Floyd's opponent is ridiculous (8-4 is still a pretty dominant fight), and for the poll question to make it sound like I said each won 5 is dishonest.

[IMDAZED]

Don't have my scorecard on me. Maybe I'll re-score the first half of each later on to refresh and let you guys know. I don't think at all that 4 rounds in either fight for Floyd's opponent is ridiculous (8-4 is still a pretty dominant fight), and for the poll question to make it sound like I said each won 5 is dishonest.

Floyd won the third (CLEARLY) and the fourth was up in the air as Zab landed one big left early and then was dominated for the remainder of the round. Zab won the first two. After that Floyd dominated. Zab won three rounds (four at BEST) over the full twelve.

[GrandpaBernard]

Floyd won the third (CLEARLY) and the fourth was up in the air as Zab landed one big left early and then was dominated for the remainder of the round. Zab won the first two. After that Floyd dominated. Zab won three rounds (four at BEST) over the full twelve.

Yep, Mayweather painted Zab with bodyshots.

[Bogotazo]

Floyd won the third (CLEARLY) and the fourth was up in the air as Zab landed one big left early and then was dominated for the remainder of the round. Zab won the first two. After that Floyd dominated. Zab won three rounds (four at BEST) over the full twelve.

Again, don't have my scores on me, but it doesn't sound like there's much difference between our views. Not sure why giving four rounds to Judah is being treated like blasphemy.