Could JMM be the P4P no 1?

[Welsh Jon]

Since I (and most people) believe that Juan Manual Marquez got the better of Manny Pacquiao I don't think it's fair that Marquez should be rated below Pacman on pound for pound lists. So really it should be between JMM and Money Mayweather for the number 1 spot.

After knocking out Ricky Hatton Floyd Mayweather Jr. has retired and made comebacks a couple of times. What JMM has achieved since 2008 is clearly greater than what the part-time boxer Pretty Boy has done in the same time. Especially when you consider Marquez SHOULD have one at least 1, possibly both of his bouts with Pacquiao during that time period.

For me the only reason why Mayweather could possibly be ranked ahead of Marquez is that when they met Floyd did dish out a dominant defeat to the Mexican warrior. But since this is a pound-for-pound list and they met at a weight at which Mayweather was a lot more comfortable, can this head to head be ignored and can Marquez's greater achievements in recent years mean that he should be ranked as the pound-for pound king?

What do you guys think?

[IronDanHamza]

I think it's arguable, yes.

I'd have either him or Mayweather.

Mayweather because he dominated him.

On the other hand, Marquez has a better win last sat than Mayweather has in recent years and infact ever had.

So personally it's between Mayweather and Marquez. For me.

[bojangles1987]

If you think Marquez beat Pacquiao, then yes you could put him there without it being a stretch at all.

[daggum]

i'm pretty sure omar narvaez is the p4p number 1.

[Weebler I]

Marquez should be pfp #1, he beat Pacquiao and the Mayweather fight was a joke.

1. Marquez
2. Pacquiao

[QuebecSTAR2]

Since I (and most people) believe that Juan Manual Marquez got the better of Manny Pacquiao I don't think it's fair that Marquez should be rated below Pacman on pound for pound lists. So really it should be between JMM and Money Mayweather for the number 1 spot.

After knocking out Ricky Hatton Floyd Mayweather Jr. has retired and made comebacks a couple of times. What JMM has achieved since 2008 is clearly greater than what the part-time boxer Pretty Boy has done in the same time. Especially when you consider Marquez SHOULD have one at least 1, possibly both of his bouts with Pacquiao during that time period.

For me the only reason why Mayweather could possibly be ranked ahead of Marquez is that when they met Floyd did dish out a dominant defeat to the Mexican warrior. But since this is a pound-for-pound list and they met at a weight at which Mayweather was a lot more comfortable, can this head to head be ignored and can Marquez's greater achievements in recent years mean that he should be ranked as the pound-for pound king?

What do you guys think?

1. floyd
2. pac
3. marquez

the only reason why i have pacquiao ahead of marquez:
marquez struggled more with his opponents,
where as pacquiao totally dominated his opponents.