Do you have Marquez above Barrera an Morales?

[daggum]

yes and especially when you consider the only fight he's clearly lost was to mayweather. all his other fights were either robberies or super close fights that could have gone his way.

[Pacroid]

Yes, He proved it 3 times

[etlux]

yes and especially when you consider the only fight he's clearly lost was to mayweather. all his other fights were either robberies or super close fights that could have gone his way.

exactly. Marquez never got blown up like barrera and morales did. those boys got straight owned annihilated and KO'd brutally at times, but no one has mastered marquez ever

[Phil Ivey]

It baffles me that he was in the shadows during the Barrera/Morales era partly because some of the decisions he made regarding his opponents. He's truly a warrior and amazing to watch, I bet the Mexicans love him now - I'm curious to see how his homecoming is going to turn out - I hope there's going to be a coverage it.

He's above Barrera and Morales imo, his consistency as a top fighter is outstanding and to have the courage to fight Pac at this level is astounding.

[fceeviper]

I was saying he was greater before last night.

Same here.

I've always held him up there with Salvador Sanchez, Julio Cesar Chavez, and Ricardo Lopez.

Easily.

[lefthook2daliva]

marquez easily dominated barrera 118-109 in 2007 so yes he's probably greater than them both.

Although at this point I would place Marquez higher than Barrera in a career comparison, you must not have watched the fight. Maybe you weren't into boxing way back then and you're basing your argument on Boxrec. It was actually close and some folks had Barrera w/the win. In any case, nobody called it any kind of domination...like I said you probably didn't watch it.

As far as your attempt to preempt anyone bringing it up, though JMM is a little older, Barrera had many more hard miles on him at that point in their respective careers. In case we're talking about things you weren't around for, folks used to deride JMM for not taking risks and having boring fights.

[BROOKLYN CESAR]

well he should have his fourth title at a fourth weight so i would put him above them!!!

[El_Forklift]

At least this time Mexico got to see him do his thing against Pac this time!

[Money_May]

Yes he is and he needs to forget pacquiao now fight for a world title at 140 win that and then win a title at 147 become the first Mexican ever to win titles in 5 weight classes! He can do it but he better get moving time is against him

[clmags12]

Yes, Marquez is above both but all three have very respectable careers.

Wish Marquez fought Hamed. I was curious to see that one played out.