Comments Thread For: Disgraceful Scores Mar Excellent Rodriguez-Rosinsky

[TaurusJ27]

The fight reminded me of Wolak-Rodriguez that was on espn friday night fights earlier this year. From the way the commentators were talking I expected this fight to be a draw also.

[ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY]

If every round is razor close, and a judge gives a fighter every single razor close round, that's biased. Those scores show the judges were paid off or biased.

even if they honestly thought the one fighter won every round???

[Walt Liquor]

I dont see how in the *** u can give rodriguez 5-6.

I dont care so much cuz i had rodriguez, amd menefee was blowing rosinsky the entire figt but 3 judges 10-0 is ***ed up. No way u gove rodriguez those rds. Not if effective aggression, ring generalship and cleanxpunchjng are criteria used to score the rds.

[Walt Liquor]

Ok, Rodriguez fanboy with his picture in your post. Take that off before hoping to be viewed as impartial or worth listening to.

No, you're an idiot.

[PACnPBFsuck]

I dont see how in the *** u can give rodriguez 5-6.

I dont care so much cuz i had rodriguez, amd menefee was blowing rosinsky the entire figt but 3 judges 10-0 is ***ed up. No way u gove rodriguez those rds. Not if effective aggression, ring generalship and cleanxpunchjng are criteria used to score the rds.

Are you drunk?

[Walt Liquor]

Are you drunk?

For a change no, i havent had a drink in almost 6 weeks.

But im trying to put my daughter to sleep with 3 nepheews in thd house and i was yellijg at them while typing on the iphone.

Did u understand the post at least?

[PACnPBFsuck]

For a change no, i havent had a drink in almost 6 weeks.

But im trying to put my daughter to sleep with 3 nepheews in thd house and i was yellijg at them while typing on the iphone.

Did u understand the post at least?

yeah i got it, if you had a droid, you could be watching the undercard of the Donaire vs Narvaez

[Walt Liquor]

Surprised by the reaction on here.

This must be a case of a fight being much different in person than on TV because having a seat, where I had a close and clear view of the fight, and judging the fight in an impartial manner, the only rounds a judge could've given to Rosinsky are the 3rd and 4th rounds.

Rosinsky was strong, easily the stronger fighter, and the aggressor, but he was rendered largely ineffective throughout the fight. Most of the clean and effective punches were landed by Rodriguez; the punch output had to be around 70-40. This fight looked similar to Jessie Vargas' fight on the Mayweather-Ortiz undercard because of the strength and punch output difference, but Rodriguez did a much better job of winning the individual rounds and contorlling the action.
Frankly, giving Rosinsky more than 2 rounds would've been shocking to anyone at the fight, including Rosinsky fans, who became noticeably quiet after the 4th round and could tell their man was down by a huge margin. I'm going to watch the fight from the Shobox telecast to see what could've possibly influenced this sort of reaction.

Nonsense. I was watching rosinsky's fans going nuts in 5-6.

Terribly inaccurate post on your round timing unless you were sitting wher you couldnt hear anyone sitting ringside on the camera side.

I thought edwin was the winner for sure but he did almost nothing in 5-6-7. Power was blocking a lot of shots that sounded good but he kept his earmuffs on in close and was nice with his elbow d.

I liked edwins up and down combos. But he didnt throw enough of them, and he threw a lot of 1-2 punch combos.

Curt menefee was cheerleading for power like lampley cheerleads. It was bad. I had rodriguez winning by 2. I know he won 1, 2, 8, 10 clearly. 5-6 clearly for power.

[bojangles1987]

even if they honestly thought the one fighter won every round???

If every round is razor close, there's no way you can justify not giving the other fighter some of those rounds. Not in my opinion anyway.

[Walt Liquor]

yeah i got it, if you had a droid, you could be watching the undercard of the Donaire vs Narvaez

I have a computer too, its on that, but im trying to put the damn baby down. I snuck in my 3rd viewing of the rod-power fight b4 putting her down.