Comments Thread For: Disgraceful Scores Mar Excellent Rodriguez-Rosinsky

[ИATAS]

I didn't keep score I was just enjoying the fight. After the final bell I didn't know who won, I felt it was really close could have gone either way. Then the scores were read Every single round? really? god I hate boxing at times. At least give dude a few rounds I mean he fought his heart out.

[NECK SNAPPER]

you know boxing is fixed if there is no rematch to that fight. not because
the judges blew it because the fans deserve it.
the only one who knows for sure is rosinky & edwin.

[bojangles1987]

Ridiculous crap. Nothing else to say.

[Heru]

Surprised by the reaction on here.

This must be a case of a fight being much different in person than on TV because having a seat, where I had a close and clear view of the fight, and judging the fight in an impartial manner, the only rounds a judge could've given to Rosinsky are the 3rd and 4th rounds.

Rosinsky was strong, easily the stronger fighter, and the aggressor, but he was rendered largely ineffective throughout the fight. Most of the clean and effective punches were landed by Rodriguez; the punch output had to be around 70-40. This fight looked similar to Jessie Vargas' fight on the Mayweather-Ortiz undercard because of the strength and punch output difference, but Rodriguez did a much better job of winning the individual rounds and contorlling the action.

Frankly, giving Rosinsky more than 2 rounds would've been shocking to anyone at the fight, including Rosinsky fans, who became noticeably quiet after the 4th round and could tell their man was down by a huge margin. I'm going to watch the fight from the Shobox telecast to see what could've possibly influenced this sort of reaction.

[Mikhnienko]

Surprised by the reaction on here.

This must be a case of a fight being much different in person than on TV because having a seat, where I had a close and clear view of the fight, and judging the fight in an impartial manner, the only rounds a judge could've given to Rosinsky are the 3rd and 4th rounds.

Rosinsky was strong, easily the stronger fighter, and the aggressor, but he was rendered largely ineffective throughout the fight. Most of the clean and effective punches were landed by Rodriguez; the punch output had to be around 70-40. This fight looked similar to Jessie Vargas' fight on the Mayweather-Ortiz undercard because of the strength and punch output difference, but Rodriguez did a much better job of winning the individual rounds and contorlling the action.

Frankly, giving Rosinsky more than 2 rounds would've been shocking to anyone at the fight, including Rosinsky fans, who became noticeably quiet after the 4th round and could tell their man was down by a huge margin. I'm going to watch the fight from the Shobox telecast to see what could've possibly influenced this sort of reaction.

Seemed pretty much the opposite on TV. Rosinsky had the much better connect % and i thought Rodriguez won 3-4 rounds max being as generous as possible.

Speaking of fans, ER's fans cheering like crazy even though everything was blocked was the norm and to be expected but the way they boo'd Rosinsky after the fight showed what low class clowns they were.

[ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY]

TV is definitely much different than being there live, always has been...I was there front row as I said and Ill say that there is NO QUESTION AT ALL that Edwin won the fight...it just wasnt the cakewalk that the scores woul dimply...also, though, realize that a fight could be EXTREMELY close every single round and yet one could get all 10 RAZOR close rounds...so in that case a 10-zip score woul dnot reflect that competitivess of the bout at all...

[PACnPBFsuck]

TV is definitely much different than being there live, always has been...I was there front row as I said and Ill say that there is NO QUESTION AT ALL that Edwin won the fight...it just wasnt the cakewalk that the scores woul dimply...also, though, realize that a fight could be EXTREMELY close every single round and yet one could get all 10 RAZOR close rounds...so in that case a 10-zip score woul dnot reflect that competitivess of the bout at all...

WOW, that's crazy cause most on the RBR thought it was gonna be a draw.

[Mikhnienko]

TV is definitely much different than being there live, always has been...I was there front row as I said and Ill say that there is NO QUESTION AT ALL that Edwin won the fight...it just wasnt the cakewalk that the scores woul dimply...also, though, realize that a fight could be EXTREMELY close every single round and yet one could get all 10 RAZOR close rounds...so in that case a 10-zip score woul dnot reflect that competitivess of the bout at all...

10-0 shows that Dibella ensured his Hispanic cashcow had won before they ever stepped in the ring.

[bojangles1987]

TV is definitely much different than being there live, always has been...I was there front row as I said and Ill say that there is NO QUESTION AT ALL that Edwin won the fight...it just wasnt the cakewalk that the scores woul dimply...also, though, realize that a fight could be EXTREMELY close every single round and yet one could get all 10 RAZOR close rounds...so in that case a 10-zip score woul dnot reflect that competitivess of the bout at all...

If every round is razor close, and a judge gives a fighter every single razor close round, that's biased. Those scores show the judges were paid off or biased.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Had Rodriguez winning but I wasn't impressed with either guy, not sold on any of them and I doubt either will make serious noise in the SMW division in years to come. It wasn't the fight a few made it out to last night, it was decent at best, they hardly displayed any good skills.