Pre-Clottey Pacquiao vs. Floyd Mayweather today - Who is higher in the ATG list?

[dosepulgada]

Just take a look at the P4P rankings to see who's better that time.

My take: Pac but by a very narrow margin.

[immortal tech]

lol at these silly *******s Floyd was always more highly regarded then Pacquiao nobody ever ranked Pacquiao higher then Floyd before 2008 not even in the alltime Asian boxers top P4P list

[miron_lang]

Floyd is greater even if you count Pacquiao's win against the 168 pound cheater Margarito.

It dont matter when your talking about. Floyd Mayweather is the best there is, the best there was, and the best there ever will be

WTF??!!

LOL

Pac


Floyd needs to beat him to move a lot closer. and beat Martinez @160 to overtake.

[Phenom]

WTF??!!

LOL

Pac


Floyd needs to beat him to move a lot closer. and beat Martinez @160 to overtake.

after what fight did Pacquiao overtake Floyd?

[lebrick]

after what fight did Pacquiao overtake Floyd?

cotto fight for me..

7th division..

[Phenom]

cotto fight for me..

7th division..

alright you look at the number of divisions they hold belts in as measure makes sense but I disagree

[lebrick]

alright you look at the number of divisions they hold belts in as measure makes sense but I disagree

the hatton KO was somewhat an equalizer.. pac's 4th lineal title in his 6th division.

the 147 belt versus a solid champ opposition breaks the equalizer..

[BABYBOXER]

what is FOTD?

[DLT]

I always say "who cares" to questions like this. Lets be real here. Most people love Pac and hate Floyd so he's going to be rated higher legacy wise if they are even remotely close. However, both of there legacies wont be fulfilled unless they fight eachother.

If they do fight then the winner will have the greater legacy. Just let it play out and stop making these kinda threads or post, weather youre a Floyd or Pac fan. They should fight and the winner will be on top in pretty much every way unless youre the ultimate hater

[miron_lang]

after what fight did Pacquiao overtake Floyd?

Lets have the Title fights. to be clearer.

Pac
Sasakul
Ledwabba
Barrera
Juan Manuel Marquez
Diaz
Hatton
Cotto



Floyd

Hernandez and Corrales
Castillo
Gatti
Baldomir
Dela Hoya




Not even close if you look it this way