Pre-Clottey Pacquiao vs. Floyd Mayweather today - Who is higher in the ATG list?

[Sugar Sting Ray]

Everything Pacquiao did after winning the welterweight title against Cotto is eliminated from boxing memory. Everything Floyd Mayweather did in the amateurs and ALL of his fights as a professional are counted - all the way to his so-called "knockout" or Ortiz.

Who is greater in the all time great list?

[Floyd is Great]

Floyd is greater even if you count Pacquiao's win against the 168 pound cheater Margarito.

[KingTito]

I definitely went with Pacquiao.

[Bombs]

Oh Pacquiao by a landslide. No doubt about it. The whole world thinks the same and it will reflect on your poll.

[tangalog2200]

Everything Pacquiao did after winning the welterweight title against Cotto is eliminated from boxing memory. Everything Floyd Mayweather did in the amateurs and ALL of his fights as a professional are counted - all the way to his so-called "knockout" or Ortiz.

Who is greater in the all time great list?

pac of course....

floyd is a universe behind pac...

eric morales beat floyd even in greatness...

[Check_hooks]

Pac was always better than floyd but he cemented his legacy when he became the first person to KO Morales

[straightleft]

Pacquiao no doubt! Pac by then at the age of 24 was already a champion at 19, 2 lineal champ and 3 division champ while Floyd was nowhere to be found.

[Sugar Sting Ray]

Oh Pacquiao by a landslide. No doubt about it. The whole world thinks the same and it will reflect on your poll.

Wow!

I knew Pacquiao would win this poll but this landslide was totally unexpected. No wonder Sucker Puncher is so insecure.

This thread might as well be closed before Floyd really gets annihilated.

[edgarg]

Pacquiao is higher.......... and a mystery.

I voted Pacquiao, because he has climbed farther with the most disadvantages.

Just want to ask, does anyone know a poster named Tiozzo, maybe uunder a different name? I've been barred from his thread just below and I've never heard of him. A first for me.

[edgarg]

Pac was always better than floyd but he cemented his legacy when he became the first person to KO Morales

Not only the first person to KO Morales, but the only person who did. And he did it twice.