Who finishes higher all time list Floyd or Manny?

[UTEP]

Floyd will finish Top 5 ATG whether people hate him or not. Pac will be like top 30.

No he won't. Not even close. His resume isn't even close to that kind of consideration, and the opponents aren't there over the last six fights to get him there either, unless he suddenly goes to middleweight, which is ridiculous.

That's offensive as hell to true ATG top 5 fighters like Armstrong, Robinson, Charles, Duran etc.

Mayweather may finish higher than Manny but he doesn't even sniff a top 40

So this is the mentality of hardcore Floyd fans around here, Top 5 of all time

[straightleft]

The floydiots will not even use their very little brain cells left and will say Floyd but then even after they watched Floyd on video admitted he cherry picked all his fights the answer remain the same. SMH

[Kagami Taiga]

After a win over csnelo and a win over the Garcia/mathysse winner it will undoubtedly be floyd

[Jack Napier]

Floyd will finish Top 5 ATG whether people hate him or not. Pac will be like top 30.

:laugh::laugh::laugh:

anyway, Pac is much greater than Floyd; Floyd is simply better

[Toyman]

in my opinion, floyd ducked too many fighters to be considered greater than pac.


floyd ducked margarito whereas pac took him on, giving up 20 lbs in the process.

manny has demolished too many ATGs to be threatened by floyd as this generation's greatest.

if you inserted floyds entire resume into manny's, his best win might not even make it into mannys top 5.

sorry, its just the truth.

[hhs661]

It really all depends on Floyd's run with Showtime. Longevity should count for something. Especially if he ends his career fighting a guy like Lucas next(if he gets past Canelo.) With Pac's decline and Floyd's consistency at the top, I myself, believe it's really close at the moment. But why knock the two legends? They gave us multiple memorable performances even if they both failed to fight one another during their reigns