jose luis castillo vs zab judah at 147

[BLOODSHED]

Spinks(former undisputed champ) is better than Cintron. Cintron was still a prospect.

judah's biggest win was spinks and thats it. his resume isnt much better

[masterdirector]

****ty logic.

Not as ****ty as saying you won't respect Zab for not fighting Margarito though. how about flipping that statement.

Who the **** has Margarito fought? 6 Heads Lewis? BFD, seriously. He ate Mayorga's leftovers. Lewis, Cintron, and Hercules Kyvelos or whatever. Who else did he beat? Two of those guys were prospects btw.

[masterdirector]

You guys who think that stoppage in Zoo/Judah fight was not legit think about L.J. or G-Man than think again if the stoppage was right or not.
Or just get in that ****in ring and get hit for once. Keyboard warriors.

G-man had it coming. Dog fighting idiot he was.

LJ was 35 and on the way out.

This means nothing. Zab was the favorite going into the fight. He was winning until the knockdown. It was to unify the titles. The fight is stopped and Judah isn't even given the benefit of the doubt? Come on.

[Tha Greatest]

Zab isn't like a god eitehr..


Got KO'd by Tszyu and outboxed by Spinks(which he avenged impressively) but also had a hell of a fight by a ancient Pineda and journeyman Corley...

[ShowStopper]

G-man had it coming. Dog fighting idiot he was.

LJ was 35 and on the way out.

This means nothing. Zab was the favorite going into the fight. He was winning until the knockdown. It was to unify the titles. The fight is stopped and Judah isn't even given the benefit of the doubt? Come on.

Let me ask you this. If it was up to you to let Zab continue but you knew that chances are 50/50 that he will either win or get braindamaged and paralysed(and damn giving 50/50 is giving a huge benefit of a doubt). Will you let him go on and fight. Will you risk his life, health and career.

[masterdirector]

Zab isn't like a god eitehr..


Got KO'd by Tszyu and outboxed by Spinks(which he avenged impressively) but also had a hell of a fight by a ancient Pineda and journeyman Corley...

you got no argument. just have to try pointing the light back to Judah. Quit dodging it fool. Margarito hasn't done **** yet you respect him more because you think Judah is the n word.

[masterdirector]

Let me ask you this. If it was up to you to let Zab continue but you knew that chances are 50/50 that he will either win or get braindamaged and paralysed(and damn giving 50/50 is giving a huge benefit of a doubt). Will you let him go on and fight. Will you risk his life, health and career.

I'd let Judah decide. He'd decide to keep fighting. And he'd finish and beat the **** out of Tszyu.

[BLOODSHED]

Can someone answer this?

No man. It aint like that. You said Judah has to deserve your respect when hes done a hell of a lot better than Margarito. Beaten better people. More talented. Better gift physically (speed, reflexes). The undisputed champ and he still doesnt have your respect but Margarito does?

[Tha Greatest]

Lets just drop the subject man..

We both have different opinions..

[ShowStopper]

I'd let Judah decide. He'd decide to keep fighting. And he'd finish and beat the **** out of Tszyu.

Its an easy way out. What would YOU do? Letting decide a fighter who just got hit with the biggest Hail Mary of his career whether he can continue or not is not very reasonable.
Dont forget that boxing is sport first.