TRUE OR FALSE: pacquiao has too many loses to be considered in ATG

[Kagami Taiga]

thats just plain ******. boy ppl are on a roll with the threads today.

[Xyei]

A potential ATG thread right here!

Seriously though... This is a silly question. PAC has more than made up for his few losses. Definitely ATG material. No question about it.

[-Kev-]

losses define greatness

But there's nothing great about getting KTFO multiple times against unknowns.

[Paclan]

True- Only undefeated fighters can be ATG's

maybe one or two losses is acceptable, but definately not 3

[Canelo Phresh]

is this **** thread day??????????

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=507915

naw this pistol whip classic is the ****thread of the day but this is a contender.

[Paclan]

But there's nothing great about getting KTFO multiple times against unknowns.

Pacquiao wasn't even sexually mature yet when he got knocked out

[-Kev-]

The standards for being great have lowered considerably. Soon the top 10 ATG will be completely changed with new fighters.

[Spit Venom]

What does Mayweather have to do with this topic? If I started a topic asking if Morales had too many loses would you have responded the same way?

u kiddin me, it was at the beginning of his career and he was a skinny teeny...

He has too many losses against unknown guys. 2 is too much.

It's okay to have losses, but it better be against greats or at least good fighters. For example his loss against Morales is okay because Morales is a great. But the Singsurat and Torrecampo losses are shameful.

um, jes.

undeafted= unproven. its a rule. didnt want to pick sven otke since its too obvious.

[dosepulgada]

definitely false. A lot of fighters have 0 L in their resume but most of them has the remote possibility being an ATG.

pacquiao has to be considered as one of the GoATs. Only floydiots doesn't believe that.

[-Kev-]

Pacquiao wasn't even sexually mature yet when he got knocked out

Age is a bad excuse. How old you think Benitez was when he lost a 15 round decision to top 10 ATG Sugar Ray Loenard?


Inexperience is more like it. Don't use age as an excuse.