Where will this Ortiz win put Mayweather on the P4P list?

[ablindwatchmakr]

sergio deserves number 1 nonito number 2 pac 3 may 4

This is one of the more reasonable things I've seen lately.

The question is: Who has looked amazing fighting the best?

This order sounds about right, although pac is only ahead of mayweather because of activity

[Grand Champ]

If you're talking about The Ring.

The Ring will probably put him in the top 5 P4P. And #1 WW.

I personally will have him at #1 because he has never "lost" that spot.

^^
This right here.

Changes nothing really, I love Ortiz but he'll be no 42 who tried and failed. Always great to watch Floyd break down fighters in the ring regardless..

[ablindwatchmakr]

Tell me why. Out of who you mentioned, only Sergio deserves the accolades. Please elaborate.

Intuitively, I'd just base it on the last few years of activity. I think there is a tendency in boxing to keep people on these lists for too long. I'd say 2 years of awesome performances against excellent opponents. How you weigh those two variables is up to you.

[bojangles1987]

At 9 or 10.

Misread the question, Mayweather should be #1 if he wins. I already have him at the top spot.

[shade darkar]

#2........................

how do you justify mayweather going to number 2 when he beats ortiz? ortiz isnt even top ten. and if you look at todays welterweights, it isnt a hot division like it used to be.

skills wise we all know mayweather is right up there, probably the best, but a win over ortiz doesnt prove much imo.

[shade darkar]

Number 1.

Pacquiao definitely deserved it when Floyd left, but every time Floyd returns he fights better opponents. Not only that, but Floyd beat the same guys Manny's been beating, before Manny beat them.

yeah but pacquiao tko'd cotto. imo thats a better win than any welterweight win mayweather has.

[Larry the boss]

how do you justify mayweather going to number 2 when he beats ortiz? ortiz isnt even top ten. and if you look at todays welterweights, it isnt a hot division like it used to be.

skills wise we all know mayweather is right up there, probably the best, but a win over ortiz doesnt prove much imo.

cause floyd was #2 and only droppd due to inactivity..........

[Larry the boss]

yeah but pacquiao tko'd cotto. imo thats a better win than any welterweight win mayweather has.

not really,floyds mosley win was better considering "WHEN" he fought him

[shade darkar]

cause floyd was #2 and only droppd due to inactivity..........

you said it right there, he WAS number 2, now he isnt, shouldnt he have to earn it?

[KingTito]

#2 for sure. I think Ortiz would be a great win for him.