why is Maidana and Matthysse so overrated?

[Mr Burns]

I get that people don't like Alexander on these forums but don't act like Matt was dominating that night it was a real close fight and not an Alexander vs Kotelnik type of a fight be real bro

I think he's more questioning how you scored it a draw. Matthysse had a 10-8 round so if it was 5 rounds a piece he would of won by 1 point & if you gave Alexander 6 rounds he wins by 1 point. How did you end up scoring it a draw? Did you give Matthysse only 4 rounds but 2 of those 10-8 on your scorecard?

[Phenom]

I think he's more questioning how you scored it a draw. Matthysse had a 10-8 round so if it was 5 rounds a piece he would of won by 1 point & if you gave Alexander 6 rounds he wins by 1 point. How did you end up scoring it a draw? Did you give Matthysse only 4 rounds but 2 of those 10-8 on your scorecard?

you are allowed to score a round 10-10 you know that right?

[the niggest]

errr mathysse pretty much beat boh zab and devon

maidana is overrated though because he is exciting and ppl dig that but i think even his biggest fan boys know deep down that he aint that good

barely beat corley and morales lol

[uoykcuf]

errr mathysse pretty much beat boh zab and devon

maidana is overrated though because he is exciting and ppl dig that but i think even his biggest fan boys know deep down that he aint that good

barely beat corley and morales lol

Maidana had a close fight against Khan, he was winning rounds against Khan.

[Phenom]

Maidana had a close fight against Khan, he was winning rounds against Khan.

how many rounds would you say Maidana won?

[Battle*Hardened]

Maidana is so underrated it's not even funny.. Bunch of noobs always saying how one dimensional and dumb he is.... They don't see his sneaky accuracy and timing. The way he can cut off the ring. He always lands more and more as the fight goes on suggesting he figures his opponents out. That doesn't sound like a dumb fighter to me.

People keep saying Maidana is overrated and Matthyse is good are ******ed.... Maidana has done way more including beating Matthyse as an amateur.

[Hi-Dro]

Maidana arguably beat Khan. The fight could have gone either way, and no one can dispute that, as the fight was that close. The same goes for the kotelnik fight, as many believed he was given the W over Maidana, as a result of him having a home advantage. Maidana is not overrated, as many of us know the tools he possesses. He's not the most skilled, but he is definitely competitive against the elite of 140, and one can make a case for him being undefeated. Not to mention he demolished the guy who is going to face who many regard as the best in the sport on Sep 16. So what is it? The guy is certainly world class.

Matthysse, however seemingly appears overrated, as his exposure came at the hands of Judah- who Amir destroyed- and a close fight with Alexander who technically was coming off two losses against Bradley and Kotelnik. Perhaps, his domination over Corley who Maidana had struggled with put him in the same perceptive level as Maidana. who da **** knows up in hurrr?

[jenandkira]

They are not overrated. Maidana made Ortiz quit and had a close fight with Khan [and only haters would deny that Khan is world class] and only Americans call Matthysse overrated, but they know he beat both Judah and Alexander.

[Beater_of_ass]

Maidana definitely is, Lucas I think is a solid fighter a lot better than Maidana I think. He won both fights he "lost" and I think he'll make Morales look his age, as he is a better technical fighter than Maidana is.

[amir is king]

Amir owned both of them