ESPN Hot Button: Should Paul Williams retire?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Evil Abed
    The Darkest Timeline...
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Nov 2009
    • 21964
    • 979
    • 1,320
    • 30,552

    #1

    ESPN Hot Button: Should Paul Williams retire?

    That's enough punishment, Paul
    Guryashkin By Igor Guryashkin
    ESPN.com
    Archive

    There was a time when Paul Williams could give and take blows in equal measure. His appetite for absorbing punches matched his hunger for throwing them. With a raptor-like reach longer than that of heavyweight champion Wladimir Klitschko, coupled with his ability to throw upwards of 1,000 punches a night, the 6-foot-1 Williams towered over his shorter, slower and overwhelmed foes.

    For the fight fan, it was a dream. For the man in the opposite corner, a tall, blurry nightmare.

    But should the man who for years was considered the most avoided fighter in the sport now seriously consider retiring?

    Yes. And rightly so.

    In last November's rematch with Sergio Martinez, Williams found himself on the receiving end of a punch even he could not stomach. Williams dropped his right hand, Martinez unleashed a piston-like overhand left, and Williams was unconscious before he hit the canvas. Eyes glazed and motionless on the floor, the Williams of old passed.

    In his July 7 return, against Cuban Erislandy Lara, Williams looked bad. To argue otherwise would be as ridiculous as the scorecards that were returned in Williams' favor. No one thought Williams was sharp. Not the fans nor his trainer George Peterson (who told his fighter in the corner that he needed a knockout), and I don't believe that Williams, deep down, believed it himself.

    Lara built a plan from a blueprint that Sergio Martinez had drawn up, and now anyone can follow it. Williams drops his right hand, leaves himself open to lefts and, at age 30, can seemingly do nothing to stop it. Williams is loyal and, unlike his right hand, won't drop George Peterson. He should, if he wants to continue. Some coaches can take their charges only so far.

    If a third fight with Martinez gets made, then Williams needs to ask himself if the purse is worth the damage he would take in a fight in which he would be a heavy underdog. Some things you can't put a price on. So why not just call it a day?

    Williams can look back on his career with a great degree of pride. He routed Winky Wright and outlasted Antonio Margarito. He defeated Martinez in their first dazzling encounter. But if a damaged Williams chooses to continue taking fights, there may come a day when he won't be able to remember those highs at all. Perhaps it's time for "The Punisher" to stop punishing himself.

    http://espn.go.com/boxing/hot?id=6836806
    47
    Hang it up.
    38.30%
    18
    Keep going.
    61.70%
    29
    Last edited by Evil Abed; 08-10-2011, 02:42 PM.
  • uoykcuf
    Banned
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jun 2011
    • 4597
    • 114
    • 157
    • 5,044

    #2
    If he doesn't I'd like for his next opponent to be an easy fight even if he isn't paid much for it. Not another rising prospect tho and stay the hell away from south-paws.

    Comment

    • Evil Abed
      The Darkest Timeline...
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Nov 2009
      • 21964
      • 979
      • 1,320
      • 30,552

      #3
      Time to change -- but not retire
      By Brian Campbell
      ESPN.com
      Archive

      It wasn't so much what Paul Williams did -- or didn't do -- in his controversial win over Erislandy Lara that was most concerning. It was what he said that raised the biggest flag.

      In separate interviews with HBO's Max Kellerman before and after the bout, Williams' summation was that no adjustments were necessary. "I'm a fighter 'til the end," he said. "With me, what you see is what you get."

      That single-minded mentality has the oft-avoided former pound-for-pound phenom on his way out of the sport at 30 years old.

      But does it have to be that way?

      The rail-thin Williams -- a freak of nature at nearly 6-foot-2, with the wingspan of a heavyweight -- has too many physical gifts to be talking retirement now.

      Although it's true he has seems to have lost a step due to age and mileage, Williams is far from physically shot in his reaction time or speech -- the way a 28-year-old Rid**** Bowe was, for example.

      Williams' biggest issue appears to be overcoming his own stubborn self.

      Too comfortable with his enabling trainer George Peterson, Williams has a one-dimensional style of relentless pressure that not only fails to accentuate his natural strengths, it places him unnecessarily in harm's way.

      If willingly giving away his height and reach advantages weren't enough, Williams has naively focused too much on punch volume and not enough on his eroding technique.

      Simply put, he has grown ignorant of his own need to evolve.

      It's not often that a fighter this committed to action fighting comes under fire. But Williams has too many physical advantages to neglect defense and rely so heavily on his well-respected chin to bail him out.

      Williams may "still fight like he's broke," as Kellerman noted before the Lara fight. But after watching him eat flush left hands for 12 rounds, it's obvious he shouldn't have to.

      Watching someone with limitless potential settle for anything less than finding out just how good he can be is the hardest thing to swallow. Based on Williams' most recent performances -- including a devastating KO loss to Sergio Martinez -- even his most ardent supporters are running out of ways to defend him.

      But consider me someone who still believes.

      Upgrading to an elite trainer would be a great start, as would developing a career-extending jab. An upright, defensive posture and commitment to defense wouldn't hurt, either.

      Too late to teach an old dog new tricks? Only Williams can decide that.

      He can continue to pursue a third fight with Martinez and walk right into the fire with guns blazing before retiring for good. Or he can take a hard look in the mirror and decide that now is the time for change.

      http://espn.go.com/boxing/hot?id=6836806

      Comment

      • Phenom
        Phenomdeaux
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • May 2010
        • 12218
        • 494
        • 363
        • 101,474

        #4
        he should Molina he would look better in that fight IMO


        to me he is no more shot then say Cotto and most def has more in the tank then Mosley and Margarito

        Comment

        • Mr. Fantastic
          Banned
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • May 2008
          • 19036
          • 527
          • 1,328
          • 20,027

          #5
          Stay away from southpaws? This is freaking boxing, you gotta give Williams his props for fighting people that he has some sort of weakness against. He's not taking the "great" matchmaking to greatness like some other boxers.

          Williams shouldn't retire. He can still beat most of the 154 pound boxers.

          I've talked a lot of shit about Williams but I really mean what I say above.

          Comment

          • Paclan
            Banned
            • Feb 2011
            • 2824
            • 151
            • 61
            • 3,310

            #6
            he's still young- just needs to work on his technique

            definately needs a new trainer.

            Comment

            • Evil Abed
              The Darkest Timeline...
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Nov 2009
              • 21964
              • 979
              • 1,320
              • 30,552

              #7
              http://espn.go.com/boxing/hot?id=6836806

              Get on ESPN and vote as well.

              Comment

              • Ray*
                Be safe!!!
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Jul 2005
                • 44867
                • 1,654
                • 1,608
                • 558,890

                #8
                I dont think he should retire, He should IF he isnt going to change his style/trainer or his matchmaking, Like Fantastic said he should stay away from southpaws or whoever his matchmaking should make sure he doesnt fight southpaws, He struggled against Quintana in their first fight getting hit with punches after punches, Then he got KO by another lefty in Martinez after struggling in their first fight, Then he cameback against another lefty and got beat hard, If they stay away from southpaws then continue if not find him a trainer that would show him how to fight a lefty, You cant go face first everytime in the ring especially against a southpaw, I like Williams because he actually chase the fights that we the fans wanted to see.

                Comment

                • Bushbaby
                  Wild Apache
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Dec 2008
                  • 23513
                  • 727
                  • 370
                  • 32,078

                  #9
                  He should hang em up. He's given simply to much to a sport that didn't deserve or appreciate a throw back fighter. He's one of the last of a dying breed. He should leave it to B-Hop who's a little more capable of holding it down.

                  Comment

                  • gomez1012
                    Amateur
                    Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
                    • Jan 2011
                    • 23
                    • 1
                    • 0
                    • 6,073

                    #10
                    Hire Manny Steward

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP