Explain how Manny or Floyd's resume is better than Oscars?

[Cotto's Father]

You holding onto them, when I just explained Oscar been fighting since when ? If Oscar started in 97 he wouldn't have fought them, so now what ? Argument out the window isn't it

Oscar was champion was Floyd beat him. And Floyd beat him at 154. I repeat 154, SUPER WELTERWEIGHT. Not at 147 when Oscar beat them. So how you really want to play it lol

And I'm not the one who made the thread

Ok Floyds win over Oscar was good but no 1 on his resume compares to Whitaker or Chavez

[J Dubb II 330]

Chavez was old, Whitaker, quarteyand sturm all beat DLH, watch them fights before you look on box rec, look at the punch stats in those fights completely one sided and not in DLHs favor

[IronDanHamza]

It doesn't matter, Larry.

Because everytime someone explains something to you in black and white you ignore it and then ask the same question 2 weeks later.

I must have broken down to you atleast 3 or 4 times now why Hopkins isn't a Top 20 ATG. Yet, you still say to people including myself 'prove me wrong'

So when you ask questions like this it's literally pointless.

[1believer]

Chavez was old, Whitaker, quartey and sturm all beat DLH, watch them fights before you look on box rec, look at the punch stats in those fights completely one sided and not in DLHs favor

Yup, people seem to love to forget that, or havn't watched the fights

[bojangles1987]

The Barrera that Pacquiao killed in the first fight is better than anyone Oscar ever fought. Whitaker and Chavez were not their best when Oscar beat them, in Sweet Pea's case disputably.

[dc3383]

Put it like this you don't put jobs you got fired on your resume; so losses don't count on your resume.

[minasyan]

Agree Oscar is hard done by on this forum especially when hes has at least two big fights robbed from the judges.

I wont say he has something on Pac or Mayweather but he should be respected more.

[Cotto's Father]

The Barrera that Pacquiao killed in the first fight is better than anyone Oscar ever fought. Whitaker and Chavez were not their best when Oscar beat them, in Sweet Pea's case disputably.

Lol,Whitaker and Chavez>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Barrera.get real

[Rassclot]

Lol,Whitaker and Chavez>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Barrera.get real

if you count Chavez then you have tto count Oscar's loss to them.

[Steak]

Whitker and Chavez were definitely not prime, and the Whitaker win was pretty controversial. I had it a draw.

On the other hand, DLH(in my eyes) deserved a win over prime Trinidad and definitley deserved to beat Mosley in their 154lb rematch, and Mosley was far closer to prime then than he was against Mayweather and Pacquiao.

DLH beat Hernandez(and Gatti) before Mayweather did, and quicker. also his wins over Molina, Ruelas, Gonzalez, Carr, Castellejo, and Campas are worth noting. I thought he legitimately beat Quartey, but thats a very controversial fight.
I think everyone already knows DLH didnt deserve to beat Sturm. He just wasnt a middleweight.


Oscars career is a mess. Its hard to rate him against certain other fighters, because a lot of it depends on how you scored his fights. All in all his controversial fights include Mosley II, Trinidad, Quartey, Whitaker and Sturm. Depending how you look at these fights, his record can be looked at as overrated or pretty awesome.