Teh Better Achievement: Fighter of the Decade or Undefeated?

[waxfondler]

You could have just asked: 'Are you a ***** or a *******?'

The greater achievement is not being a Pac nuthugger.

On a serious level I think this is a biased question in favour of Manny. It would be wiser to compare opponents etc. We can't say yet! Also Pac doesn't deserve fighter of the decade...

its not biased at all... quality of opponents is quite comparable... people can **** on floyds choices @ WW, but floyd was a beast @ 130-135.... and people criticize pac for selling out lately, but you cant forget mexicutioner status he had....

[Phenom]

4 time lineal champ in 4 divisions. case closed. those are facts.

undefeated records dont hold the same weight as they did in the past... calzaghe, JCC jr, floyd, etc.... undefeated.... big whoop. in the era of padded records, protected fighters, overpaid prospects, not a big accomplishment.... plus, floyd will ALWAYS have the reputation of cherrypicking to remain undefeated (also convenient "retirements").... like pac will have the reputation of catchweights & in-house mismatches.... BOTH were phenomenal in the lighter weights though.

either way, i would rank b-hop over BOTH guys anyway....

lineal champ is not a fact or official it been broken so many times and different people see it a different way.

being undefeated is a fact and official being the FOTD and P4P king and the hero of Asia is all opinions

[jrosales13]

They both mean ****.

The fan boys from both sides, don't understand that.

[waxfondler]

lineal champ is not a fact or official it been broken so many times and different people see it a different way.

being undefeated is a fact and official being the FOTD and P4P king and the hero of Asia is all opinions

beating the man, that beat the man, is a BIG deal homie... lineal champ MEANS something. its a DEFINITIVE way to determine a champion. also, knocking out your opponents is quite definitive as well. since winning by decision doesnt necessarily reflect the TRUTH. boxing is littered with HORRIBLE decisions.

youre clouded by the undefeated record.... you claim his record is fact.... yet his record lies to you. he LOST to castillo the first time. the judges' OPINION scored the fight for floyd.

so by your logic, lara LOST to p-will.... FACT is that lara lost to p-will right???? even though MOST people had lara winning that one.

[ModernTalking]

lineal champ is not a fact or official it been broken so many times and different people see it a different way.

being undefeated is a fact and official being the FOTD and P4P king and the hero of Asia is all opinions

So fighting bum is the fact LOL.

[V.WEBB]

Ask this next year when Floyd adds Manny to his undefeated record.

[AKATheMack]

The fan boys from both sides, don't understand that.

I know and its pointless to try to get them to see it. Both sides are just 2 pieces of the same puzzle.

[jrosales13]

I know and its pointless to try to get them to see it. Both sides are just 2 pieces of the same puzzle.

These 2 fan bases might be the worst fan base since the Tyson days.

[sugersean69]

undifieted was beter then figter of decades. Maywither is da bests. hahahahahahahahahaha

[Kenny MF Powers]

These 2 fan bases might be the worst fan base since the Tyson days.

Have you seen your sig lately..?