Did Haye really beat Valuev?

[chav]

It was such a **** fight I've only watched the replay once and both times I thought Haye was lucky to get the belt if I'm honest. Valuev wasnt much better but I didnt think Haye would take his belt in Germany with that performance.....I might have missed a fair bit due to losing interest but i'm not watching it again lol

[SP1]

What does that even mean?!?!

Yeah my bad for not reading over my comment. What I was trying to get at was that Haye did not deserve to take away the championship belt.

[Die Antwoord]

everyone lost that night. Haye, Valuev, the fans, the german people havent been subject to such an attrocity since Stalin invaded. Worst fight Ive ever seen, but Haye is exciting!!!!!BECAUSE HES BLACK AND HAS CORN ROWS AND SAYS ****** THINGS.

Haye vs Valuev made Wlad vs. Ibragimov look like Gatti vs. Ward.

[hweightblogger]

I didn't bother to score the fight because of how terrible it was. But i do remember thinking with the reputation Germany has favouring home fighters i thought Haye had made the fight too close. I was a big Haye fan at the time so didn't really care if he deserved it or not (like alot of people).

Has anybody watched the fight again and scored it? Would be interested to hear peoples opinions on the fight (other then it being ****).

Other then the 12th i don't remember there being a clear round for either guy as so few punches were being thrown.

For me personally it's less important whether Haye actually won the fight.

For me more important is that Evan Fields performed better than Haye yet lost.

Had Evan Fields won against Valuev, Wlad would have unified the belts long time ago, because I believe that Evan Fields has a genuine desire to unify.

Additionally we would have seen Wlad-vs-Fields which on Wlad's resume would look better (despite Evan's age)