Antonio Margarito vs. Victor Ortiz - Who wins?

[TheTruth!]

Ortiz had most of these advantages over Maidana as well.

Maidana has a lot of single shot power, and Ortiz was struggling to make 140.

Margarito has ZERO power, and Ortiz is solid at 147.

Margarito's career is over without his plaster wraps.

[Steak]

Berto and Ortiz were both very tired after 6 rounds.

I thought Ortiz still had plenty of activity throughout the 12 rounds, considering the damage he had taken.

and Ortiz's stamina was noticably worse at 140lbs.

[DonairesRevenge]

Maidana has a lot of single shot power, and Ortiz was struggling to make 140.

Margarito has ZERO power, and Ortiz is solid at 147.

Margarito's career is over without his plaster wraps.

Ortiz folded late against Peterson.

[Pacquiao'd]

Vic would break cheatos face into pieces

[Khalid X]

Would you feel the same about Ortiz if his opponent was Manny Pacquio?

Before Ortiz beat Berto I stated this (along with Bradley not being able to beat Margarito) I really don't get the point of this statement. Hell IIRC it was even in a thread in which you participated in, but even at that Manny is going to fight Ortiz eventually so why would I let that affect my opinion on the matter.

[Cuauhtémoc1520]

Ortiz has more speed then Marg
Ortiz has more power
Ortiz throws the better combination
Ortiz has more boxing skills
Ortiz has the better footwork


only thing Marg has on ortiz is size and thats irrelevant since he never fights tall anyway

You could say that about every fighter Marg has ever faced...hahaha

Yet he wins.

[DonairesRevenge]

I dont know how anyone could think a folder like Ortiz could deal with what Margarito brings. It would be a one-sided beatdown in Margaritos favour after 4 rounds.

[The Big Dunn]

Before Ortiz beat Berto I stated this (along with Bradley not being able to beat Margarito) I really don't get the point of this statement. Hell IIRC it was even in a thread in which you participated in, but even at that Manny is going to fight Ortiz eventually so why would I let that affect my opinion on the matter.

Is that a yes or a no?

[Khalid X]

You could say that about every fighter Marg has ever faced...hahaha

Yet he wins.

minus the power argurement, you can say Calderon had those same advantages over Segura but we all say how that turned out.

[TheTruth!]

You could say that about every fighter Marg has ever faced...hahaha

Yet he wins.

With plaster !

Without plaster he gets destroyed by past prime Mosley and midget Pacroid.