What is Miguel Cotto's best win?

[The Hammer]

Miguel Cotto has an excellent resume.

Who would you say is Miguel's best win?

[Kambumbo]

Shane Mosley

[McFearless]

I'd say Shane Mosley

[onechance87]

zab judah maybe?

[DarchinyFAN]

Biggest stature win was Shane Mosley
Most dominant he looked against a good opponent Quintana

[Willy Wanker]

sugar shane no doubt.

cotto does have a great resume.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Easily Mosley, very good win that was.

[Wazaa..]

I'd say Judah.

Mosley was not a very good win because Mosley was already old and shot by the time Cotto fought him and the fight is still a matter of dispute to this very day.

"Maybe" beating an old shot fighter is not something to be proud of.

Judah was still prime when Cotto gunned him down so I go with Judah.


Cotto has a great resume but he has a knack for failure when the fights actually count for something. But I give him props for taking on all the top names of his time.

[Mr Randy Watson]

I'd say Judah.

Mosley was not a very good win because Mosley was already old and shot by the time Cotto fought him and the fight is still a matter of dispute to this very day.

"Maybe" beating an old shot fighter is not something to be proud of.

Judah was still prime when Cotto gunned him down so I go with Judah.


Cotto has a great resume but he has a knack for failure when the fights actually count for something. But I give him props for taking on all the top names of his time.

??? the guy only lost to a cheater who damaged him... and followed that loss with a match up against one the best p4p... how is that a "knack for failure" ?

[Phenom]

for a guy with a "great" resume he really doesn't have lot of great wins I would vote Mosley even tho he was past his Prime.