Above 130, does Pacquiao hold a win better than Martinez's win over Paul Williams?

[RockyB]

yes
Cotto achieved more at WW than Williams did at MW

I agree with this. maybe also Hatton.

[ChampBox@PR]

Cotto and Hatton!!!

[Jack Napier]

Shouldn't we consider where Cotto was at in his career? How he looked against Clottey?

yes we should
Cotto at WW in 2009>Williams at MW in 2010
how everybody look against Clottey except Pac?
he gives them hell, then he shuts down and loses
Cotto fought with a cut eye for 9 rounds that night
it was a gutty performance
it speaks better for him that the decision was close
WTF did Williams do at MW?
SD on Martinez? UD old/inactive Winky? Andy Kolle? :laugh:

[Doctor_Tenma]

Are u serious? Paul williams was a hype job who got beaten by midget qiuntana.

Then Paul avenged the lose in an impressive fashion, also beat Margarito at WW, something Cotto failed to do. Alot needs to be considered, but go ahead and vote.

[ChampBox@PR]

Willaims came From looking like **** against cintron at JMW, dont forget that!!!!

[Doctor_Tenma]

Willaims came From looking like **** against cintron at JMW, dont forget that!!!!

Your choice to do that but I wouldn't use that to measure up on anything, Cintron quit. Lets leave that for another day though.

[ChampBox@PR]

Then Paul avenged the lose in an impressive fashion, also beat Margarito at WW, something Cotto failed to do. Alot needs to be considered, but go ahead and vote.

Cotto **** Quintana on the first try!!! Williams got outclassed by quitana, and the catch Quintana cold on the 2nd fight!

[studentofthegam]

Only Cotto IMO. Though Margarito was the most shocking by the design to me. For you guys calling PWill a hype: You dont know **** about the sport. I wont say more.

[ChampBox@PR]

Your choice to do that but I wouldn't use that to measure up on anything, Cintron quit. Lets leave that for another day though.

Ofcourse you wont, it goes against your BS, but is a fact that he looked like straight up ass!!!

[Doctor_Tenma]

Ofcourse you wont, it goes against your BS, but is a fact that he looked like straight up ass!!!

Don't even get me started on that bullshit man. The man quit, you think otherwise so be it.