How would 154 lb Winky handle margorito at 154

[-Huey-]

Winky always did great against bums...so I say he beats this bum too.

[Jack Napier]

Winky has problems with volume punchers
but he would still UD Tony
Tony not as fast with his volume as Williams

[Dorian]

I'd take Winky by UD but it'd probably be a lot closer than most think.

Agreed. I'd favor Winky 55-45.

[Pullcounter]

Could he just out box him or would it be tough cause of that pressure

winky is too big. there's a chance marg outworks winky tho

[jrosales13]

Margarito was not good at 154. He lost to Daniel Santos twice at 154, and that was the best guy he fought, and Santos isn't even that good to begin with. Winky beat guys like prime Mosley twice, draw with a prime Jermain Taylor at 160, close fight with Hopkins at 170, close fight with a prime Vargas who some say should've gone to Winky, beat a past prime but still tough Quartey.

Margarito was nowhere near Winky's level. Let's not get Winky confused with Clottey who barely throws punches and uses the ear muff style of fighting. Winky was a very busy fighter back in the day and I just don't see how Margarito at 154 would be a competitive opponent for Winky. Maybe at 147 against a weight drained Winky Wright he'd do good.

Stop talking about a sport that you know absolutely nothing about.

[Kagami Taiga]

Stop talking about a sport that you know absolutely nothing about.

i mean even with that said, margarito didnt look that good in the santos fight. i mean i dont think much of santos and if i rememer correctly it was a close fight(the second one) in which both guys seemed like they were hurt a few times. not to mention that he really didnt bully santos at all well not the way he usually does. im sure that fight was a big reason as to why margs decided to stay at 147.

[Bushbaby]

This fight is simply unfair,for Margarito.Margarito isn't stronger than Winky.If Margarito cannot push U back,it's a wrap.Winky had an amazing jab.I see Margarito powerless blows bouncing off of the Winky defense with Winky walking Margarito down & simply punishing him for 12 rounds.I'd be suprised if Margarito even won a round.

Sam Soliman is just not a good comparison.Solomon was a legit middleweight to go with his high volume.Margarito has only fought at 154 a couple of times.Winky stood up to much bigger & stronger men like taylor,B-Hop & had Tito's power looking non existent against that high guard.Winky walks U down & he'd walk Margarito clean outa that ring.

[Bushbaby]

Winky always did great against bums...so I say he beats this bum too.

Actually Winky fought down to opponents.A mediocre fighter would have Winky fighting down to his level.But the better the fighter,the better Winky fought.Except for the Punisher.