Who has the better WW career Floyd or Manny

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Mayweather...................

[KingOfBox]

Whats crazy is the amount of questions that will be answered if/when these two fight...

1. Who is the best p4p
2. Best of this generation
3. Arguably the best WW all-time
4. Cash Cow beyond their respective fight (loser would lose ppv buys for future bouts)
5. If Pac's 8 title run was for real
6. If Floyd's undefeated record is for real
7. The worth of Sugar Shane's legacy
8. Most importantly boxing's future if they don't break PPV record

[mozzer101]

I'd say as of now but if he keeps fighting weak boxers than i would say PBF.

[KingOfBox]

and what happens if pac KO shane.. does that mean pac is better than floyd??

Fair enough... I would say its more impressive.. But it wouldn't make him better. They are different styled fighters... I give credit where its due and Pac is a hell of a fighter worthy of our utmost recognition. If Pac KO Shane then he is deserving of his kudos as well... Shane is no slouch man... He's got bombs, and has handspeed...

[daggum]

FLoyd Mayweather Jr....He beat Baldomir when Many WW were not willing to fight Baldomir. Margarito, Shane, and a lot of WW at that time were ducking the hard hitting baldomir. Then He Fought Hatton who was undefeated at that time. Many say Hatton was a 140 lbs fighter. But they either forgot or dont know Hatton had a belt at 147 after beating collazo at 147. So hatton was undefeated at 147 as well. He also fought Mosley when Mosley was coming off 2 back to make KOs and Floyd was coming off a 2 year lay off & a tune up with Marquez. Floyd dominated both those fighters. Floyd's JMW resume is also better then Pacquiaos. Pac fought Margarito a WW fighter at 150 for the 154lbs vacant belt. Margarito hadnt won any fights at 154 and had been off a whole year. Not only that he was fighting without his wraps. Floyd fought Oscar at 154 affter oscar ko mayorga and fernado vargus..

who wasn't willing to fight baldomir? the guy ****** and everyone wanted a shot at him but he fought gatti because he knew he would lose to a top welterweight.

[daggum]

Whats crazy is the amount of questions that will be answered if/when these two fight...

1. Who is the best p4p
2. Best of this generation
3. Arguably the best WW all-time
4. Cash Cow beyond their respective fight (loser would lose ppv buys for future bouts)
5. If Pac's 8 title run was for real
6. If Floyd's undefeated record is for real
7. The worth of Sugar Shane's legacy
8. Most importantly boxing's future if they don't break PPV record

that was already settled when floyd fought baldomir.

[size15shoe]

Its kind of a toss-up


Mayweather's best fight at 147 was Zab Judah. He moved up to 154lbs to fight Baldomir, but miraculously skipped over Paul Williams, Antonio Margarito, Miguel Cotto (the fight that EVERYONE wanted), and a PRIME Sugar Shane Mosely.

Even that fight with Baldomir was bull****, if he REALLY wanted to make an impression he could have fought Winky Wright, Michele Piccirollo, Vernon Forrest (RIP), Fernando Vargas, ect at 154lbs.. He picked on the sorriest fighter at 154 just to get a belt. NO ONE on this board can convince me that Mayweather made more $$$ fighting Baldomir than he COULD have fighting Cotto. Nope. No way.

Manny's record at 147 against Hatton, De La Hoya, Cotto, Margarito and Clottey are a little better IMO. The competition at 147 hasnt really spectacular, and it hasnt really been popping since Williams, Cotto, Mayweather, Mosely, Margo, De La Hoya, ect..(Although some up and coming fighters like Ortiz are changing the landscape a bit)

I'll pick Manny, but it could honestly go either way.

[Phenom]

Obviously Manny. Baldomir, Judah, Hatton, Marquez, Mosley does not beat Cotto and Clottey alone. Once Pac beats Mosley there won't be a debate.

the great Marquez alone is better then Cotto and Clottey put together

[Larry the boss]

floyds been the linear champ at 147 2 times..has won the ring,ibf,wbc,ibo..and beat the wba champ.so there ya go

[RockyB]

Mayweather...................

Based on?

Pacs wins at WW is much better than Floyds.