Is there anybody can beat Pac at the same day weigh-in fight today at 147?

[Rassclot]

when has pac came in higher than 148?

[puga]

Well you asked and they answered in that thread. Not sure why you had to make another pointless thread if they already gave you what you were hoping couldn't be proven wrong.

thats the point they did'nt.......with the exeption of big guys( way bigger than pac), has there been a fighter who's beaten a 17 lbs bigger guy?...it got answered but it did'nt fit the criteria, ....and the answers were either fighters from the 1890 - 1920 without the weight diffrence or the weightclass it happened or made up.....

[whirlwind]

No doubt! Pacquiao would be GOAT! same day weigh in fight. Today current fighters between 135-147. I can see nobody can beat him at 147 and including Mayweather.

[Reloaded]

there has never been a fighter in history that has beaten a fighter 17 lbs ( or more )biggger than him that is close to pac's size or smaller........watch , somebody is going to post some **** about fighters from the 1890's to 1920's....correct me if im wrong please!

Because they never forced them to come down to fight them which weakens fighters , they always went up to their division and fought the full version , when the bigger man is not weakened the saying is true " a good big man will always beat a good little man " when you weaken the big man it changes everything , Pac as been matched perfectly by manipulating the system that the man in the street would not even notice or bat an eye too , all he sees is one guy flogging another , but to a student of the game Pac is a top liner handled by experts to make a commercial monster ,,,,

vs Floyd he will show why Jmm went life and death with Pac , why he has only dominated fighters that had weight restrictions or coming off bad beatings or both , there is always some bullshi!t with Pacs fights , when its all fair , Floyd will bring Pacfans to the world of reality .

[puga]

Because they never forced them to come down to fight them which weakens fighters , they always went up to their division and fought the full version , when the bigger man is not weakened the saying is true " a good big man will always beat a good little man " when you weaken the big man it changes everything , Pac as been matched perfectly by manipulating the system that the man in the street would not even notice or bat an eye too , all he sees is one guy flogging another , but to a student of the game Pac is a top liner handled by experts to make a commercial monster ,,,,

vs Floyd he will show why Jmm went life and death with Pac , why he has only dominated fighters that had weight restrictions or coming off bad beatings or both , there is always some bullshi!t with Pacs fights , when its all fair , Floyd will bring Pacfans to the world of reality .

so your answer is no right?....thats what i thought...

[-Boxzilla-]

thats the point they did'nt.......with the exeption of big guys( way bigger than pac), has there been a fighter who's beaten a 17 lbs bigger guy?...it got answered but it did'nt fit the criteria, ....and the answers were either fighters from the 1890 - 1920 without the weight diffrence or the weightclass it happened or made up.....

well with criteria of exact weight, around the same 'size' so no hws your prob not going to get a modern era answer. not with so many weight classes and them being so close together.

[Spacey1991]

Correct me if I'm wrong. All Pac fights at welterweight and above, he didn't weigh in more 148. By today standard most of these boxers at lightweight rehydrates more or less at 147 fight night. So basically Pac was a lightweight in old days standard "same day weigh in fight". Now my question is....is there any fighter right now between 135-147 who could beat Pac at the same day weigh in fight at 147?

When Manny was a lightweight he used to rehydrate to 146ish on fight night.

[Reloaded]

so your answer is no right?....thats what i thought...

What your saying is there any current JW that can beat Pac , its not a really big deal when you consider you dont a great choice , Khan and Bradley is your options and both have a lot more chance than , Margo ODH Cotto and Mosley had , Pac has not fought an elite WW without some bull**** going on and neither has Floyd , only Floyd is not milking the system the way Pac is , cant wait for Floyd vs Pac its got to happen because of the money , then Pacfans will see how much hype there has been for both , either Pac will treat him like Cotto or Floyd will box his ears off ,

[puga]

well with criteria of exact weight, around the same 'size' so no hws your prob not going to get a modern era answer. not with so many weight classes and them being so close together.

dont worry about all that....simplified for you...
here's my criteria: (thegreatA has provided a very very good stats as usual)
close to manny's size or smaller (close to manny's weighclass or below)
not from the 1890 - 1920's or so era
name other fighters who has beaten guys 17lbs bigger (or more) than him...(no joke fights)
..if you think pac vs margs was a joke dont even bother responding...

[puga]

When Manny was a lightweight he used to rehydrate to 146ish on fight night.

so did all of his opponnets...the size diffrence was only around 4 lbs.....