Max Kellerman calls Pacquiao the greatest fighter ever! Do you agree?

[chiguy91]

interesting comments in this thread....
it's his opinion i guess, so i'm gonna let that be and not try to argue.
i'll just say i don't think he is there yet. he is an ATG though

[Chopper417]

Many respected historians have come round to the believe that Pac is the greatest of all times and nations.

He quite possibly is. On his day, doing what he can do, he would be expected to beat anyone. Overwhelms people mostly, like a human jack in the box exploding on you from everywhere.

My dear God dude u have to be f***ing kidding me. I'm sorry bro this is just pure ignorance/******ity/c**k sucking..completely absurd. You sir are absolute f**king moron.

Manny is a top 25 ATG and IMHO.

[-Spinal-]

BS like usual. So what Pac has done before supposely losing to Floyd counts for nothing at all then? YOu achieve Jack when you are retired in your prime years like Floyd is, and then putting all your eggs in one basket landing the jackpot of beating Pac. Yes how Pac beat Hatton and DLH will always be more respected and awed than how FLoyd beat them so apply your rules.

So who had the better and more "respected win, Gamboa over Solis, or Pacquiao over Solis?

Gamboa knocked him down 5 times and stopped him in 4 in 2011. Pacquiao stopped him in 8 back in 2007.

Pacquiao beat the younger, fresher, undefeated version of Solis. While Gamboa beat him years later but in more exciting and how you call it "respectable" fashion.

So who gets more respect for the win, using your own logic of course? Don't try to change your logic now, let's be fair, treat all fighters the same.

[jrosales13]

BS like usual. So what Pac has done before supposely losing to Floyd counts for nothing at all then? YOu achieve Jack when you are retired in your prime years like Floyd is, and then putting all your eggs in one basket landing the jackpot of beating Pac. Yes how Pac beat Hatton and DLH will always be more respected and awed than how FLoyd beat them so apply your rules.

Who said that? Are you mentally ******ed? Serious question? Are you legally mentally ******ed? I would really like to know this

And, BTW the same goes for Floyd. You do know Floyd has had a career before the Oscar fight right?

Yes Pac is the greatest southpaw of all time.

No he's not. Yes, he's top 3, at best #2. But, not the GOAT.

Pac beats the Cottos, Margaritos, Clotteys, Hattons like no one ever did or could,

More importantly than who is when, you dumb fuck

so apply your rules of how you beat people that is important. SRL and Duran wouldnt do to 18lb heavier margarito what Pac did.

You want to know what Duran or SRL would do that version of Maragrito? You're acting like that was the same Marg of 2004. JUST STFU, that was a washed up Marg. That win means ****. Duran already beat way bigger and better guys than that version of Marg like Barkley and Castro.

He beats the Morales, Barreras, JMM, Hattons, Cottos, Margaritos of this world.

More importantly than who is when you dumb fuck.

That in all is comparable to anything duran ever did.

Duran win over a prime Leonard ****s on anything Pac has ever done. And, that was a smallish borderline past prime Duran.

Most experts have no problem having Pac above SRL and Duran and you make out as if you are an authoritive figure or something and you know something other people dont. You dont!

Only F'ing idiots like you have Pac over Duran.

Don't fucking respond to me about historic topics if you only started watching boxing a couple years ago. My tolerance for idiots like you is running low. It's obvious that you have no idea WTF you're talking about. Just STFU, and read so you can learn some stuff.

[MrRolltide91]

LOL @ hugh grant. u just talking bs.

[IronDanHamza]

Who said that? Are you mentally ******ed? Serious question? Are you legally mentally ******ed? I would really like to know this.

I would like to know the honest answer to this question also.

[UglyPug]

pacquiao is the best southpaw of all time. he's somewhere around 7-10 ATG as of now.

[Steak]

I really dont see how anyone could have Pacquiao over Duran. Duran beat top competition from 130lbs to 168lbs, thats just as much weight jumping as Pacquiao. add in the fact that Duran beat more top competition, fought successfully over 3 decades AND has the better big wins, and...yeah, I just have no idea how you could have Pacquiao over Duran.

[johnm is...]

Who said that? Are you mentally ******ed? Serious question? Are you legally mentally ******ed? I would really like to know this

And, BTW the same goes for Floyd. You do know Floyd has had a career before the Oscar fight right?



No he's not. Yes, he's top 3, at best #2. But, not the GOAT.



More importantly than who is when, you dumb fuck



You want to know what Duran or SRL would do that version of Maragrito? You're acting like that was the same Marg of 2004. JUST STFU, that was a washed up Marg. That win means ****. Duran already beat way bigger and better guys than that version of Marg like Barkley and Castro.



More importantly than who is when you dumb fuck.



Duran win over a prime Leonard ****s on anything Pac has ever done. And, that was a smallish borderline past prime Duran.



Only F'ing idiots like you have Pac over Duran.

Don't fucking respond to me about historic topics if you only started watching boxing a couple years ago. My tolerance for idiots like you is running low. It's obvious that you have no idea WTF you're talking about. Just STFU, and read so you can learn some stuff.

LOL. Beat down.

[IronDanHamza]

I really dont see how anyone could have Pacquiao over Duran. Duran beat top competition from 130lbs to 168lbs, thats just as much weight jumping as Pacquiao. add in the fact that Duran beat more top competition, fought successfully over 3 decades AND has the better big wins, and...yeah, I just have no idea how you could have Pacquiao over Duran.

There isn't a single logical or reasonable argument for Pacquiao being greater than Duran. Not a single one.