Floyd Mayweather is retired ...PERiOD!

[DLT]

Those fights don't make anyone P4P material. JMM is JMM at 135, not at 147 looking like cream filled cookie. Mosley being inactive and overtrained and clearly a shell also does not make someone P4P material. He won them, big deal. Not enough to be ranked P4P in my eyes.

I'm talking about being ranked P4P. If Pac beats Mayweather, it'll be good enough to keep him P4P. Mayweather beats Pac, then he can go back to the top spot. Its a legit win. My view is, Pac, if he doesn't blow out Mosley in 3-4 rounds, then his top spot is in danger as well. And if he selects another no-hoper, then he'll be off the top spot as well.

you cant say that Mosley was "clearly a shell" when he just destroyed the most feared & hottest man in boxing in Margarito. You can say he's clearly a shell at this moment but you are as good as your last fight and the fight before Floyd he looked like a monster

[*dNNy!bOx.]

He got talent, to bad his talent bringed the hateness to.

[V.WEBB]

There is no reason for him to be in the P4P talks because he is retired. If that is the case then why not bring in Oscar and Tito?
Anyone that has him in the P4P rankings is a tool warehouse!

to me only fighters that are active and who have not come out and stated that he is retired should be ranked.

1. sergio martinez
2. manny pac
3. Nonito Donaire

Have whatever opinion you would like, but the logic in the bold is not sound at all. Why? Because he's fought much more recently than those two have.

[V.WEBB]

Good im fed up with his name hogging the limelight.

LOL. Its a mythical list to begin with.

[RL_GMA]

LOL. Its a mythical list to begin with.

In which many fans of fighters hold highly when comparing their favorite fighters' past opponents with their potential or next opponent. Nah, never seen that happen on here though

[V.WEBB]

In which many fans of fighters hold highly when comparing their favorite fighters' past opponents with their potential or next opponent. Nah, never seen that happen on here though

If you were calling ME out, just do so. But you don't see ME on here talking about P4P this or P4P that, when comparing fighters and their opponents.

[deanrw]

Does he deserve to be ranked? No. He is too inactive. Does it even matter regardless? No.

Floyd is at the point where he does not need to be ranked. He has enough pull to fight any fighter, or for that matter, any belt real or imaginary he wants to. Most of us will even say he is still the most skilled fighter in the world and has the most financial pull.

Bullsh|t rankings mean nothing to him or Pacquiao. They are the two biggest financial bonanza's in the sport and to those directly involved, they will gladly give them what they want.

P4P rankings mean nothing anyway. They never have.

[RL_GMA]

If you were calling ME out, just do so. But you don't see ME on here talking about P4P this or P4P that, when comparing fighters and their opponents.

It's the internet, what's the point of me being subliminal? LOL and no, I wasn't calling YOU out more than stating what is pretty evident when mentioning Floyd's opponents on this site (to his hardcores) in relation to where they were on the "Mythical List".

What was the reason again Floyd's win over Mosley was so big?

[deanrw]

LOL. Its a mythical list to begin with.

Green K for the truth

[V.WEBB]

It's the internet, what's the point of me being subliminal? LOL and no, I wasn't calling YOU out more than stating what is pretty evident when mentioning Floyd's opponents on this site (to his hardcores) and how high they were regarded on that "mythical" list.

What was the reason again Floyd's win over Mosley was so big?

IMO was the fact that Shane was the man at the welterweight division, after whooping Tony's tail. Manny turned down the 14 day offer from Floyd in the mediation, so Mosley was clearly the next best person for Floyd to fight. Floyd hadn't fought a "true welter" in a while and Mosley was the one to really test him.