Tweet
#1 Pacquiao
#2 Donaire
#3 Froch
#4 Martinez
#5 Wlad Klitchko
#6 Vitali Klitchko
#2 Donaire
#3 Froch
#4 Martinez
#5 Wlad Klitchko
#6 Vitali Klitchko
-
-
Okay, three points:
1)
2) "if floyd fought marquez at 130..he would have gotten his ass whooped." I honestly can't tell if you are being serious here. Do you understand Floyd is probably the best super featherweight of all time? I know you don't think so, because you're an irrational critic of Mayweather.
3) You're post is full of ramblings about "oh so and so in his prime at their best weight would have killed floyd!" but you still haven't said who, other than Pacquiao of course, was a better option for Floyd to fight in May 2010. I'm really curious to hear who you think was.Comment
-
Okay, three points:
1)
2) "if floyd fought marquez at 130..he would have gotten his ass whooped." I honestly can't tell if you are being serious here. Do you understand Floyd is probably the best super featherweight of all time? I know you don't think so, because you're an irrational critic of Mayweather.
3) You're post is full of ramblings about "oh so and so in his prime at their best weight would have killed floyd!" but you still haven't said who, other than Pacquiao of course, was a better option for Floyd to fight in May 2010. I'm really curious to hear who you think was.
[IMG]http://i930.***********.com/albums/ad148/jonarie/Picture5.png[/IMG]Comment
-
Hatton was the lineal 140 champion when Pacquiao waxed him in 2 rounds. His best weight was 140, this is not a point for debate.
Pac was 1 fight removed from fighting at featherweight when he took on DLH who had been fighting at a 150 catchweight. So in the span of about 8 months, Manny had to climb up 3 weight classes while Oscar had to shed 3 lbs. DLH was the 2-1 favorite and EVERYONE outside of a few people picked Oscar to win by an easy KO. How'd that turn out?
Floyd had to jump from 147-154, one weight class and all he could muster was a boring split decision against a shot Oscar.
Fighting and beating Cotto (who beat Mosley) made more sense both logistically and financially. Roach doesn't pick Manny's fights, Arum does.
Cotto beat Mosley, Mosley beat Margarito, Margarito beat Cotto.
By May 8th, Pacquiao will have beaten ALL of them in dominant fashion. So all your arguing is just like trying to p*ss in the wind. Pacquiao is the #1 P4P fighter on the planet and an ATG, nothing you say or try to do will change that FACT, but thanks for playing anyway
Comment
-
as it should be...
Pac
Martinez
don't care about the restComment
-
I'm a Floyd fan and I have no issues with these rankings. I think at this point u could even put Donaire at #3. If Floyd doesn't fight this summer he should no longer be ranked.Comment
-
Hatton was the lineal 140 champion when Pacquiao waxed him in 2 rounds. His best weight was 140, this is not a point for debate.
Pac was 1 fight removed from fighting at featherweight when he took on DLH who had been fighting at a 150 catchweight. So in the span of about 8 months, Manny had to climb up 3 weight classes while Oscar had to shed 3 lbs. DLH was the 2-1 favorite and EVERYONE outside of a few people picked Oscar to win by an easy KO. How'd that turn out? Floyd had to jump from 147-154, one weight class and all he could muster was a boring split decision against a shot Oscar.
Fighting and beating Cotto (who beat Mosley) made more sense both logistically and financially. Roach doesn't pick Manny's fights, Arum does.
Cotto beat Mosley, Mosley beat Margarito, Margarito beat Cotto.
By May 8th, Pacquiao will have beaten ALL of them in dominant fashion. So all your arguing is just like trying to p*ss in the wind. Pacquiao is the #1 P4P fighter on the planet and an ATG, nothing you say or try to do will change that FACT, but thanks for playing anyway
Pac is the current #1 P4P fighter and an all time great, but if you are going to sit here and try to convice yourself that Pac's wins over Hatton and DLH were more legit than Floyd's then you are ignorant plain and simple. That would be like saying that Floyd's utterly dominant win over Marquez was more impressive than Pac's wins over Marquez, simply not true because of when they fought and the circumstances.Comment
Comment