Zab Judah Has to Be Ranked #3 at 140

[Gutz]

No way..


Khan
Maidana
Bradley


are still higher then him

Then you still have

Alexander
Ortiz

[DET. IRONSIDE]

Bradley
Khan
Maidana
Alexander
Kotelnik
Ortiz
Peterson

Zab hasn't fought any of these.

[studentofthegam]

Honestly Mabuza is not that good and was just made to look better by an unmotivated Holt so no he doesn't rank above Maidana or Devon until he gets a notable and convincing win against a top 140lber but by default he maybe at #5 or 6.

Devon didnt exactly wow us to get his spot. He KOed a shot Urango and got a gift against Kotelnik. Nobody really argued that much against him. He was a product of good timing (He didnt fool me though). Zab got a decision against Mathysse which was better judging to me than the Alexander/Kotelnik sham. Then he knocked out Mabuza who is definitely better than Urango. So why doesnt the formula work for a guy who has been to the top of the division before and has an Identical path.

I didnt see it at first but the TS is right. The only thing we are holding against Judah is his past and its not fair to a guy who if Im not mistakin has only one loss at 140 ten years ago. He deserves to be top 5 no question.

[bojangles1987]

No freaking way. If Judah fought Kotelnik, Maidana, Alexander, someone in that range, he would lose. Let alone if he fought Bradley or Khan.

[victorythagr8]

Actually judah already lost at 140. That lost became one of the funniest knock out.

But I know you meant lately.

He is not top 5 yet since he hasn't fought any of the top 5.

Its like berto. Berto only became top 3 because the top welters all beat the **** of eachother(cotto, marg, mosley, clottey) and then went on to get embarassed by atg fighter and the left the division.