Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Zab Judah Has to Be Ranked #3 at 140

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    No way..


    Khan
    Maidana
    Bradley


    are still higher then him

    Then you still have

    Alexander
    Ortiz

    Comment


    • #32
      Bradley
      Khan
      Maidana
      Alexander
      Kotelnik
      Ortiz
      Peterson

      Zab hasn't fought any of these.

      Comment


      • #33
        Originally posted by Spray_resistant View Post
        Honestly Mabuza is not that good and was just made to look better by an unmotivated Holt so no he doesn't rank above Maidana or Devon until he gets a notable and convincing win against a top 140lber but by default he maybe at #5 or 6.
        Devon didnt exactly wow us to get his spot. He KOed a shot Urango and got a gift against Kotelnik. Nobody really argued that much against him. He was a product of good timing (He didnt fool me though). Zab got a decision against Mathysse which was better judging to me than the Alexander/Kotelnik sham. Then he knocked out Mabuza who is definitely better than Urango. So why doesnt the formula work for a guy who has been to the top of the division before and has an Identical path.

        I didnt see it at first but the TS is right. The only thing we are holding against Judah is his past and its not fair to a guy who if Im not mistakin has only one loss at 140 ten years ago. He deserves to be top 5 no question.

        Comment


        • #34
          No freaking way. If Judah fought Kotelnik, Maidana, Alexander, someone in that range, he would lose. Let alone if he fought Bradley or Khan.

          Comment


          • #35
            Actually judah already lost at 140. That lost became one of the funniest knock out.

            But I know you meant lately.

            He is not top 5 yet since he hasn't fought any of the top 5.

            Its like berto. Berto only became top 3 because the top welters all beat the **** of eachother(cotto, marg, mosley, clottey) and then went on to get embarassed by atg fighter and the left the division.

            Comment

            Working...
            X
            TOP