Zab Judah Has to Be Ranked #3 at 140

[-PANDA-]

I wouldn't have him at 3 yet. He has to beat Devon to get that number(Which I think he can, not that he will, but I think he defo can). I have him in the top 10 though.

judah generally does better against boxers than he does against punchers

alexander could well be tailor made for him bruh

[ATG Fighter]

He isn't #3. He didn't even beat Mathysse imo. He should be ranked #6 atm. I'd like to see him beat a top 5 guy or actually beat Mathysse in a rematch before I put him at #3.

[Spray_resistant]

Honestly Mabuza is not that good and was just made to look better by an unmotivated Holt so no he doesn't rank above Maidana or Devon until he gets a notable and convincing win against a top 140lber but by default he maybe at #5 or 6.

[Chief2ndzOnly!]

No, Judah does not HAVE to be ranked #3...He shouldn't even be ranked in the top 5.

Agreed. Anything less than 5 and I say Zab has a strong case. But until he fights and beats either Amir, Tim, Devon, or Marcos. I cant have him in my top 5.

[Chief2ndzOnly!]

He isn't #3. He didn't even beat Mathysse imo. He should be ranked #6 atm. I'd like to see him beat a top 5 guy or actually beat Mathysse in a rematch before I put him at #3.

Your opinion is respected, but on paper he has a "W" against Lucas. How any of us feel about that is irrelevant this point IMHO.

[ATG Fighter]

Your opinion is respected, but on paper he has a "W" against Lucas. How any of us feel about that is irrelevant this point IMHO.

Even with the "W" on paper he isn't #3

[cleaner147]

Agreed. Anything less than 5 and I say Zab has a strong case. But until he fights and beats either Amir, Tim, Devon, or Marcos. I cant have him in my top 5.

whos #5 for you......

1.Brad
2.Khan
3.Maidana
4.Alex
5.???

[ATG Fighter]

whos #5 for you......

1.Brad
2.Khan
3.Maidana
4.Alex
5.???

Kotelnik???

[Irish Hitman]

Maidana or winner of Berto/Ortiz has to be next for him..

[cleaner147]

Kotelnik???

I thought he was movin up?