Who has the better legacy between Pacquiao and Duran?

[studentofthegam]

That's what I was thinking! He and they both think boxing analysis is just a matter of statistics, and that you don't need to know anything about boxing in order to analyse boxing.

I mentioned the HOF'ers Duran beat pages ago...And, these mofos' are just going around in circles...

I havn't read the thread. Seems Blackirish has already shut it down though.

But, It's Duran. Obviously, It's Duran.

Contrary to you guys' belief I say its Duran too as far as legacy.Right now. My argument was that its not Pac trumps him. It is that its not clinical for a person to pick Manny. To say that numbers dont matter and then all yall throw at me is stats then what's really the criteria? It all counts for legacy:Who, What, When, How and how many all count. That is until someone views it differently than you do. right?

[jrosales13]

Good Lord.

Why is it in all of these threads your talking utter ****?

Are you a troll? Or are you just plain uneducated?

Uneducated...He studied the wrong gam(e).

Hopefully one day he studies boxing instead of whatever gam(e) he has studied so far.

[jrosales13]

You said that Duran had a winning record against the HOF opposition he faced, which isn't true.

Show me that post where I said that....Go back and read....Then comeback and talk to me.

[Steak]

Hey I made a true statement comparing two fighters. How do you go wrong there? And yes its worthless especially here to argue what prime is. For most its when their fav loses for the first time or loses to a fighter that they have sworn hatred for. Its good that he was competitive even past his prime. Hooray Roberto! It doesnt have a damn thing to do with Pac having a better record against the top tier comp. You like to jump in conversations and change the subject. Now your ass is in the same sinking ship. BS doesnt need the blind heroics bub.

fighters Duran beat:
-Ernesto Marcel(Duran beat him as a teenager), went on to be featherweight champ and beat Alexis Arguello(Arguello would beat Olivares shortly after)
-Horishi Kobayashi, top fighter and former champ at 130lbs
-Ken Buchanan, ATG lightweight
-Guts Ishimatsu, future lightweight champ
-Esteban DeJesus, future lightweight champ
-Ray Lampkin, best at lightweight behind Duran
-Edwin Viruey, top ten
-Saoul Mamby, would desrve a decision over 140lb champ Singsurat shortly after and become 140lb champ
-Lou Biazzaro, top ten at 140lb
-Vilomar Fernandez, top ten at 135, would beat Arguello shortly after
-Esteban DeJesus, best at 135lb behind Duran
-Edwin Viruet again, top 5
-Carlos Palomino, HOF, former WW champ
-Joseph Nsubungu, top ten at WW
-Ray Leonard, best at WW, arguably 2nd best WW ever
-Pipino Cuevas, HOF, former WW champ(past prime however)
-Davey Moore, 154lb champ, would beat Benitez by KO shortly after
-Iran Barkley, 160lb champ, future 168lb and 175lb champ, had just beaten Hearns by KO
-Jorge Fernando Castro, #6 at MW, Duran beat him at 45 or something years old

fighters Pacquiao has beaten:
-Sasakul, top give at flyweight
-Ledwaba, top five at super bantamweight
-Marco Antonio Barrera, Pacquiaos best win no doubt, best at featherweight
-Erik Morales, had just gotten dominated by Zahir Raheem
-MAB again, very good win, top 3 at 130lbs
-JMM, very good win, but controversial(at least half the boxing community had Marquez winning)
-David Diaz, top ten
-Ricky Hatton, best at 140lbs
-Cotto, top 3 at WW
-Clottey, top 5 at WW
DLH and Marg were not top ranked in any division by the time Pacquiao got around to them.

[badass316]

Show me that post where I said that....Go back and read....Then comeback and talk to me.

Here, it's only been 2 pages. Page 12

I see that we're just making up HOF fighters....Good job

Again against real HOF fighters he doesn't have a losing record.

[studentofthegam]

Good Lord.

Why is it in all of these threads your talking utter ****?

Are you a troll? Or are you just plain uneducated?

LMAO. Read it all man. I delt with that issue already. Besides you are a boxingscene career sidekick so I'll only continue this conversation with your bosses. LMBAO

[msagrain]

My question is how many fights would of duran lost if im the early stages if he had tumb sewed gloved?

[studentofthegam]

Here, it's only been 2 pages. Page 12

LOL. He was gon lie too.

[IronDanHamza]

fighters Duran beat:
-Ernesto Marcel(Duran beat him as a teenager), went on to be featherweight champ and beat Alexis Arguello(Arguello would beat Olivares shortly after)
-Horishi Kobayashi, top fighter and former champ at 130lbs
-Ken Buchanan, ATG lightweight
-Guts Ishimatsu, future lightweight champ
-Esteban DeJesus, future lightweight champ
-Ray Lampkin, best at lightweight behind Duran
-Edwin Viruey, top ten
-Saoul Mamby, would desrve a decision over 140lb champ Singsurat shortly after and become 140lb champ
-Lou Biazzaro, top ten at 140lb
-Vilomar Fernandez, top ten at 135, would beat Arguello shortly after
-Esteban DeJesus, best at 135lb behind Duran
-Edwin Viruet again, top 5
-Carlos Palomino, HOF, former WW champ
-Joseph Nsubungu, top ten at WW
-Ray Leonard, best at WW, arguably 2nd best WW ever
-Pipino Cuevas, HOF, former WW champ(past prime however)
-Davey Moore, 154lb champ, would beat Benitez by KO shortly after
-Iran Barkley, 160lb champ, future 168lb and 175lb champ, had just beaten Hearns by KO
-Jorge Fernando Castro, #6 at MW, Duran beat him at 45 or something years old

fighters Pacquiao has beaten:
-Sasakul, top give at flyweight
-Ledwaba, top five at super bantamweight
-Marco Antonio Barrera, Pacquiaos best win no doubt, best at featherweight
-Erik Morales, had just gotten dominated by Zahir Raheem
-MAB again, very good win, top 3 at 130lbs
-JMM, very good win, but controversial(at least half the boxing community had Marquez winning)
-David Diaz, top ten
-Ricky Hatton, best at 140lbs
-Cotto, top 3 at WW
-Clottey, top 5 at WW
DLH and Marg were not top ranked in any division by the time Pacquiao got around to them.

Fernandez was Top 5 also at the time I believe.

[IronDanHamza]

LMAO. Read it all man. I delt with that issue already. Besides you are a boxingscene career sidekick so I'll only continue this conversation with your bosses. LMBAO

You dealt with the issue of calling Vinny Pazienza a HOF'er which however he isn't?