Does Raheem make the P4P list?

[Manny_P]

Marquez is fighting Chris John, hardly a bum should be a great fight actually. Hopefully that fight will clear the way for either fighter to get a crack at the winner of Soto vs Chi.

IMO, he is pillowed up record fighta. Marquez will show that in October.

[hectari]

YES! he belongs in the mix! this guy has tremendous talent and a beautiful jab.

[IwatchBoxing]

Raheem doesnt get on the P4P list since all he did was beat Morales...nothing big.

[Manny_P]

Raheem doesnt get on the P4P list since all he did was beat Morales...nothing big.

you crazy man. LOL!

[Tha Greatest]

hatton beat Tszyu in not bad fashion

Taylor didn't do **** but land 2 punches and his in the top 10

Raheem won 12 rounds against Morales on my card!

[Super_Lightweight]

hmm

There's a lot of fighters beating the top P4P guys this year...

Jermain Taylor, Ricky Hatton, and now Raheem!...

You're contradicting yourself on Hopkins. Was he a top guy or not. Make up your mind.

Anywho...if Hatton and Taylor can get in after fighting older, slightly faded legends, then so can Raheem. Anything else would be favoritism. Raheem won every round in my view, much better than Hatton or Taylor did when they upset their opponents.

Floyd
Wright
Pacquiao
Barrera
Corralles
Hatton
Castillo
Rafael Marquez
Juan Manuel Marquez
Antonio Tarver

Maybe I missed someone, I dunno...whoever wins Hopkins-Taylor II can crack the top 10 again.

[BLOODSHED]

Tarver beat a faded/old Jones.
Wright : Had blueprint to beating Tito from Hopkins. Beat a blown up Mosley?
Pac: one dimensional.

You're contradicting yourself on Hopkins. Was he a top guy or not. Make up your mind.

Anywho...if Hatton and Taylor can get in after fighting older, slightly faded legends, then so can Raheem. Anything else would be favoritism. Raheem won every round in my view, much better than Hatton or Taylor did when they upset their opponents.

Floyd
Wright
Pacquiao
Barrera
Corralles
Hatton
Castillo
Rafael Marquez
Juan Manuel Marquez
Antonio Tarver

Maybe I missed someone, I dunno...whoever wins Hopkins-Taylor II can crack the top 10 again.

[BLOODSHED]

Taylor is top p4p. considered one of the best before hand and then beat the p4p king who wasnt old in the ring.

[TheEvilSaint]

no, the same way jermain taylor shouldnt be in the p4p list. one win doesnt mean your p4p material, it means you just beat a p4per.

aside from hopkins, whos taylor beat?
aside from morales, whos raheem beat?

im not saying either of them suck, but they shouldnt be in the p4p list simply because of one win.

[Super_Lightweight]

hmm

Ta

rver beat a faded/old Jones.
Wright : Had blueprint to beating Tito from Hopkins. Beat a blown up Mosley?
Pac: one dimensional.

Tarver also beat top guys like Johnson and Harding. But his resume ain;t all that (which is why I got him at number 10).

You can't keep Pac put just because he's one dimensional. He slaughtered MAB, drew with JMM, and closely lost to the bigger guy in Morales in a fight in which he had a horrible cut. Pac def belongs on the p4p list.

Wright has to get credit for his long record of success. Most people picked Mosley to beat him the first time and many picked Shane again the 2nd time. Same thing goes with Tito. Many picked Tito to win (50-50). Also, Wright didn't just beat these guys, he made them look like nothing.